Re: Strange tor status...

[Roger Dingledine <arma@xxxxxxx>]

On Tue, Jun 23, 2009 at 06:03:35PM +0300, Andrei Lavreniyuk wrote:
> Who exactly can describe me why the status of ReactorRelay is not normal?
> Please check ReactorRelay's date and time. At present, concerning of the
> time differences, ReactorRelay is not included to servers list on most
> sites. In instance https://torstatus.blutmagie.de/ skips ReactorRelay.
> 
> network-status-version 2
> dir-source moria 128.31.0.34 9032

moria2 is only a v2 directory authority. You are looking at obsolete
directory authorities and an obsolete directory protocol.

There does exist a torstatus that looks at v3 information. See e.g.
http://trunk.torstatus.kgprog.com/index.php

In any case, you appear to be another of those edge cases where some of
the directory authorities can reach you, and some of them can't.

moria1 can reach you:
r ReactorRelay ekp80iSmHIIG8kfyC2wkdX9oMIs 7T+TKBsijyincvCHza7JH+TQ3V0 2009-06-23 21:48:26 86.111.64.45 9001 9030
s Exit Fast Guard Named Running Stable V2Dir Valid

tor26 cannot:
r ReactorRelay ekp80iSmHIIG8kfyC2wkdX9oMIs 7T+TKBsijyincvCHza7JH+TQ3V0 2009-06-23 21:48:26 86.111.64.45 9001 9030
s Named V2Dir Valid

ides can:
r ReactorRelay ekp80iSmHIIG8kfyC2wkdX9oMIs 7T+TKBsijyincvCHza7JH+TQ3V0 2009-06-23 21:48:26 86.111.64.45 9001 9030
s Exit Fast Guard Running Stable V2Dir Valid

dizum cannot:
r ReactorRelay ekp80iSmHIIG8kfyC2wkdX9oMIs 7T+TKBsijyincvCHza7JH+TQ3V0 2009-06-23 21:48:26 86.111.64.45 9001 9030
s V2Dir Valid

gabelmoo cannot:
r ReactorRelay ekp80iSmHIIG8kfyC2wkdX9oMIs 7T+TKBsijyincvCHza7JH+TQ3V0 2009-06-23 21:48:26 86.111.64.45 9001 9030
s V2Dir Valid

So the pattern is "America finds you reachable, and Europe finds you
unreachable."

Is your firewall set up in a funny way? Does your hosting provider have
its routing table broken?

See also
http://archives.seul.org/or/talk/Apr-2009/msg00102.html
and my followup there:
http://archives.seul.org/or/talk/May-2009/msg00036.html

Same pattern of authority opinions too!

Hm.
--Roger