[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
[tor-relays] Please help us find a working alternative to using MaxMind's GeoLite2 databases
- To: tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Subject: [tor-relays] Please help us find a working alternative to using MaxMind's GeoLite2 databases
- From: Karsten Loesing <karsten@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Wed, 12 Feb 2020 16:05:04 +0100
- Autocrypt: addr=karsten@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= mQINBE89AYYBEADDgmpfoRC8KwWcu7EOcpCt93xnNgAhMLhbk+EMdvyxEaOE0XNPZnXm2Het 2CC0kmb73BMHmhDAuM/jX7o5fPIHD6967zmiNXo2Zn+R3JRkRU2xL8TbN05PKF0vPWR2MDK3 Sh922Lrb196p4NNooYrvXoI3MGqaG8NRpyEgEAuiD/GW0CRq8JWzqmIQ54NS6t0GyV/WpFer Fh2duSxqg1wzQihnCRdsVhVhYWnN3GXPO1UMtyhnisAfhSKOMPAhftmpLSZPupTvdn/VfNYz goRVN2KYOIUXyJl/b08E1kw7e1D9tarHP2glDAzSX/FzQcYBOacSsRu+6yKiVXfWd3t9qmy2 dJuX+tgiaRiMCDXLNCbFb5ABUvZFp+QCY/VFp0gBrUG04+ekFBsf8TN3s2MT3X+9+nyO4lsx I2UCNjGUQrDK6Mcmb2TxeUVp83rFqGBd1RbQHBe7JtFyK8uAY05YO+Uk/7Yi09bje7auCGEO txDOgGEw7Dj8+AslZYhxw/QCATe3wP7r2i203VTSV/PUo+BbJQsmJa/A9WWTDWWhdCRNT9/j Uv2jky1JE56HVgNgkj4h3epoFE4tfcJtGeX0QckHspBQvUPi5UHNSE67+YH39P7C6C1XST6a EcnADC/bLa9ILKUlskW7u0GCYOAw1m41kkRnvAyhugm73CfSFQARAQABtChLYXJzdGVuIExv ZXNpbmcgPGthcnN0ZW5AdG9ycHJvamVjdC5vcmc+iQI3BBMBCAAhBQJPPQGGAhsDBQsJCAcD BRUKCQgLBRYCAwEAAh4BAheAAAoJEE79T9w/RtQeYgEP/jNhtNDpt26ICIFd5xZk2bh0UWo3 AIzyknonTWR+xc4NS8ewkv/RKe6qd9PpeOoI9SmHOJAOB8gKPqe303yhbRD7aEh9hDL1V/2S Fy3BaQI+361U1t+utAFuYM5HbcE9e+91cbqYEg0V2iUuTvd8QKH3ZL9xEh7gg6WtKCNdRR7f q8G4/9Tw+KiFvoVAAeLRNmR7wiWJMMDictiIIecMcrjtTWmaVu/guqGg6P5/rJL2ZjXd6kOl x/YqMhowisFa7JqELs7x2mNFNLV89lAKbZNLOWizyij0j4tQO99bz5StDANbJtMnhCGc9lcb KUmro66jndZgTFnM5zLTpShlF/9vSKuBTwxRmG4gM5kwQL99z8PFo2zwwFkhMEiLjM7+2USz CLZAAT6546CZxNlyLQ/2QbDRpUFAyelZEIVCXLHQYZgMpUFGnDQ4YfPrnvUo++yhHKGMAaCB StGVnjmiEcQr5JXsdGjbxpKRXfmb/kRhB9EWXZbykaPXeAdJxs5XN1RJEyMGIML2m32JK8pt ZuOQVCj2G/IuShAayUvSBR52HiRi29mviqazfyaFd8KzT0lzcq9OuA/4u/2LUO+vEMTdoCAW T/9xviFqn8A0PgApKDUmxHyafOhDhz9i7fjUYIoh0Pg8nK7UYP46cC0JYxNh4NdCXC8bOXpM DyqL8j+SuQENBFxges0BCADl0DlwB9xyg6aZaez9n+M/7Lk7+6YXMd8XBOM00Hca2s2MHa/L IATqbeTrVp2ehdgdi1cUjOE//8VSvfH/YVYEGVSseJH2dVFw4/xArbE4Lo6FX+TeU7gvRBHL NLK0D5tXyBcwtyMejyIrPJchyi0bpTTBlBxNan9eLn2EmR/k5rRZdlYb3nZsfv4B40KwHE07 IAK0jU81rab0Nvmxcp1Nx8/jeJBBpGdFHW5KFCwy/7vI1dKlSxQw9QnFmr7Le7sSomxDOpx0 ByfEiwJHdrPkW8pATAeGn4I0NsoZQrUsAt5pMHrIrPQmjx/KGf9b4cj5vxaZpCf3OUbCwHF3 /qSJABEBAAGJA0QEGAECAA8FAlxges0CGwIFCQHhM4ABKQkQTv1P3D9G1B7AXSAEGQECAAYF Alxges0ACgkQFp16MCETctMOHwf/b/GYZ2/M44gCQkx1it6NOHhqs/tANxmesT0MqFNdLQ5W CW3Nizd3hv3Zrohg8qOJyWef8g4OsKcDefmHInAVdWzF+aHFpqHHs1hcJ1R8Yhnhdk4W/Z3G 3BOdxfqsgU+ZpdF2uYcJ7gD/EsOiyrqfUYK5JJ3mcg82/PyeAionJv2QlC+Ke0JhRkCnezdL CHMnTSDFw5CQVoErS0U3RSBRGKmwMnzr0m8zRb8i5BaX7y5DtTnq4AN6s6OExtD5ifg4/d5l LrxH5N/DH82eNeYhNEo52NefQGwLSZ6Om0ELbGHfkBazI4RPyx6/YLPmC3maibBDhg8Pp1UT Gf9MRO0DUTPWD/wIPLEAIIbFikAWMD8NxJjM0Erhz24SIcrW5j0s9I/Ot+zDSwAMV1+VX0x8 8gNxvgj3AWw7OC6xefgcS7s3xqWdJ+mSAU/MtM0QznjMAwiluU7Q8RlNfY4hb3T9aJ2UQMNf ochrqpIpfpHNSA+RrIhRS3ALe9ZjDTdk+E8Ys9NHIxJl4VU2bw8d4orJ+wlq29uWF7LzXQdX 9jdN421pdNYdO8uekdOgiUezdhB0nauzrOQclIgSBdaTpFdyQmNrfSILTkzl9yJG9Jnk6MnJ PWmtNIj+CbGcArAPjtijbFnb1MiFWc7sEwlr6wRCFABmcnDWcyRDldzk+VyMd0NBjyhxO2/g t4dR9F9bYybRnk5Kv6GXQrPH7O3l6ZCkst4xQEg5JjvvV6/vOdNq0K7ngdBRDNNKc8+4BhN/ i5OLIYygPDrXUpuSJrKyij868hrXjWteZx3TEAVqqJ6NjCJdw7bx2e3N9LjDs228sEnvgs9x Vb/QnRVTYbMTnv33uTMf5c2D8p3lnjDTQsiN3r7ORgFCHpkeGbloNV14hKFu7lNbIYsngSFM vCCv0IAWVYNASp9NedTIBBisV/o21Kume5U57kWErMTBXEzyTgCfEJ5li2/7FzDr2i5omHeV GRWm3pctxaUkJHVQFlQxlFwe08JRW6MA/fj0dnQl7E82DB7iU7kBDQRcYHrxAQgAubt4HdL0 bxz2bfIbMw8nGxEvSkesxzDXYQIwdauy6BWZmIsmO7PojtZo66JDjcIAO/RkVniC6nqt5ql7 OjQZOtwpSl0auM/RDK9aL2hxG+JbDJaqZ1Q7hXF2jbRRFPyB6OFdVHRwNWPeU0Z+z2dN5IsB /kvVpa+6gYgYiNsUlBdK1/uAveRXzSJ8rMqwxC8s7gj262jauCLUvIc/0Kt7u1khnX7mcVtt zb68FvA+H7IEdVoUCSHwMNX62qnaFkEqszJvOWetCvUrzJZJ1WyZFBHu0Fxq+d6fh6qdtoMB Sq09YLBMdpnghOaSU75/wbzVe4LLIgFQP7658A/0T+3uBwARAQABiQIlBBgBAgAPBQJcYHrx AhsMBQkB4TOAAAoJEE79T9w/RtQeyn4P/RIx5idW/Q8eYpI7RCuEyQ5hp6rE1D8231zML3Tv fzfUqV+8JkzOhxf0haGEkw8jAgdrNk9Iz9tcAddNPHLFqk6ooBqV/FyemPAtN75qmL7oVbEJ DD09hNjy6Q0CBnCNxtvEh8rk/S99JDJ8+ylpufAobnE5Pep+a9iDA+qK3+d9uhTtspYd2DHx MiEwyh161NTk55hwCCfSw3134PT+euc307cugsK2kHG9/yjPlbYHLoXssJhCbzu7CKR/tFDZ PGDCR2oOaHnMSK13n9x6EGsECtH6zbTlbEMq0TtEMbrXYzDYfev3RoNZ0FmbqESxdwbepka8 CxYBFd4+7kuNiJM42CyjLgtXMiTsTxAWP1azwzMr4qHn+10g6QZfUib+VhTZNXqnxDxt1tUp GiC2UepEIXXU2PiSUQ9wqZir146YnZmMJVhGv/2EeJL1SqeHxdtp/hYEDfdN8s3Ehb0sInJy 3gAFbbvYJEYMXt5eJXcElrB8m5Sd1Mi9/sS4lWr74UNbk9KQe5yCsrsm+M4kXnUgVaHh5vI1 DIQZZmNd/vggtf4dkAJZHOPPUqfd1QGKcVeP+CnYm/aunquPJmjrzEuE8H9V0wRawgrL0Dru peBrDQqhV9snkjPFgHkNv0T2L43JZk8E2ieqOSAvMSl1nFe8cwQaXq5aH+2LxkoLis9k
- Delivered-to: archiver@xxxxxxxx
- Delivery-date: Wed, 12 Feb 2020 10:05:17 -0500
- Dkim-signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmail.com; s=20161025; h=sender:to:from:subject:autocrypt:message-id:date:user-agent :mime-version; bh=f53yPWllhvQL9JElz7GN76o+QSXEATBTMOLcMEFin8E=; b=bQlwXUBBViAyIscRKGF88uoN/wVzBwqtDEDhCCbNW1GW9g1XTAr3w6r/R0OV8ehqy8 +og+olOrFo6tIe6vL5EWZfwVBi0RO4vlCHnMZJq99AePY+gL5hWf8M6Nvpc+7Gv1osRe TsARghk6rE9lY9AQQlj0oqHGzXv+l5o8pIQ1q5YCpC4IvDIVSDhPgXrmCR+GNrUbRUyX t/CAiLw7Co6cHWtzjme8+ZMXxEmEf5Ku3OKVl/pVwBbedn/Oil9CV8VPHeCAlkJfglq8 Ic7hCcQDZFhJGasaz0CJw5mpe59ULM0eQ2GKv4WLAGC7FdO0cnT+/G9J+Iy2dzkNua+P RWMg==
- List-archive: <http://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-relays/>
- List-help: <mailto:tor-relays-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=help>
- List-id: "support and questions about running Tor relays \(exit, non-exit, bridge\)" <tor-relays.lists.torproject.org>
- List-post: <mailto:tor-relays@lists.torproject.org>
- List-subscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays>, <mailto:tor-relays-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=subscribe>
- List-unsubscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/options/tor-relays>, <mailto:tor-relays-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=unsubscribe>
- Reply-to: tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Sender: "tor-relays" <tor-relays-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10.15; rv:68.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/68.4.2
Hi relay operators,
as you might have heard, MaxMind has changed access and use of their
GeoLite2 databases:
https://blog.maxmind.com/2019/12/18/significant-changes-to-accessing-and-using-geolite2-databases/
This affects Onionoo and tor, and I'm trying to find a working
alternative on the following ticket:
https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/32978
Today I think I found a possible alternative by using data from another
provider. But before I name it here, I'd first want to find out how
accurate it is.
I tried resolving relay IP addresses of relays that have been running in
the past week and compared that to our existing lookups using MaxMind's
October database.
The result is that 7669 relays (93%) had the same country code and ASN.
I put the remaining 7% on the following wiki page:
https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/doc/MetricsGeoipComparison
I'd like to hear from you which data source is right and which is wrong
(or if both are wrong).
If you'd like to help, please leave comments on the ticket or in the
"Comment" column on that wiki page by February 19, 2020.
Thanks for helping!
All the best,
Karsten
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________
tor-relays mailing list
tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays