[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
Re: [tor-dev] Anti-censorship discussion with Briar devs
- To: tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Subject: Re: [tor-dev] Anti-censorship discussion with Briar devs
- From: Georg Koppen <gk@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Tue, 26 Feb 2019 14:19:00 +0000
- Autocrypt: addr=gk@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= mQINBFH3/woBEADHs/Q4t69Vm+mNMW0vH0Ms6HtjpzBsto/yyDAoLitmAxfMIeCuWuyuBdHR krdq9Rk5WQLYtP9eROGkuABK/UaxpLw8zkwkmqbxQ2wxytVwgonOmAFPXvPjzVy+ToJvKWJj tRGFoWwO9OEZ8q6xhVnwLUJXRQF01/XhBhU2RPzzUTHrgiY2bi6Ko34nSM8qAuidykqd/elI wE+kn4+TZ+yBC7pzwUfRK0bOqc05qtq5ooH7rYGpvdOkt9DuoFEjhLrBaL3UiP5J6D9W1Ltv 7Y239RGZyGr0wO5ClhuJwipnw6yWDt493cw4fOy7J1Lbo8dZyU4pnFIgt1Cu506/CvdQ53pR UHhCSIS/IyOiEL9PI/PPByG9UhwNQYk9U22h4MalPwa+4rZ1XA6mf5+T4QQRmghAnegPwyQw qnQzHc2ZPAal+Ill15AncyfIeMfuCLyA/TVWwQTQMzdcVwu3nljBfGOjOSTHOafBqsVlvgEo R9GB9OaTbriP7lCDJmBsgFFZ5F0m6us2pP72TpM0GMYCae7PHk7POhvcE5VJg03E3tjyQUQA zt5ZcpzjZtbcWIoYjxEJMq1Wzj0PYfZYFYZGq2lQx7xJ54gb+RlXEaKiXhDQH+EkrKZHBDWi atMbfkMWiknmn8O7VkuT4LOHsF1I9oJt1VTZ0dx2MVvk2hhs3QARAQABtCBHZW9yZyBLb3Bw ZW4gPGdrQHRvcnByb2plY3Qub3JnPokCOgQTAQgAJAIbAwULCQgHAwUVCgkICwUWAwIBAAIe AQIXgAUCUuzzUQIZAQAKCRCUNzqpS3wyI694D/90P74XiDzioGbNEH37W9P5G6unLUKp/zLf 5Ifosf6ijS5EvhKXpSXAqWu4eSpUh+i72Kr53SvzAIggWjUM61e92xt0bg4+VFaguMh6d9l0 MpDMfRJB+qoRNaDDyGk1VH9ZLBJOpTY59HcIIyg2LIMt1PHk+3npr0MnDfh/5fgyPvFRv9ZK WkKdwD4ImlqGXaxsES2pPk8tn21k7J4N8jzRAYM8oV9cMeeCbMgERilU2sRxNORs55zV6GiD A68lmwY6+OHjaKd0k+Oibs63PrTl1+P4EYBZTlXK9gSSWKiUydVP+2lQoyGVmuH0VpepEcnv zu06g+YU4TiH3f7t1chknGlEm1s872nyZo7Nd+zVDcIa4iklBMpeEsPDB6zRT7KBH+oCw5vK G+Ngjv3AO8hD2RTFHw8oAD8WPBbrOB2C9qSha/XSl7rjxTpqRillP+543xhQncC3b2x+Vk4C wlJdrjOvweMnM4xCEeg03WUeRz6a4Uuh6A9x4WZia+5Y5PrKG4GKPeBbskFdw6N0/10Gk1nF wpS42esKsrvqeltRLPzwFj0FEO+mole3y2f+iR8rJd/rik7AW9PM2YkhiF8kmcyh07GSjcCo qg7AkOJ87Bv2knZ0KYlukY5wBKK/DY55GTLGQ7w6kR/BzMOlKnru1e0+zvyZ4KijODEuaUi1 2bkCDQRblYJ6ARAAz+9QcEoz5GB8GoPRsVLDeAB33O3cHTiH/UGZjuiswnoaPZnJ+jt/1b3P CsAdWdFwj3oYHz5B2SxBl/GSslPBJAIzlLss3uGEq+DLqV5kzvL55dc3HTC8evNSJF6OBkqk 5r24yuJDbLVhpyB+34QfYN2vESBBf8usQrNqp3lfm0ePiHkLFBX8Y8hIdYg5pz5WzXywaz1t oGlyfDtfZuOqd0m8er4W5VmARb5PvB6TIGjSOhOTJPQV67c6cSxKsx+dCvgsZzBGVhlQ33nO 7yQKsvl+DFJ254s876AoyGQ7iQRxk/0/8mWOpdcmIqLjdmZNVX7OGmsJf4RfC7a+mUgImg5r za+A0qE13b+XwpzTBOgIhsFeqVySXCV865ZNSPqzOCTI5fNCa9RaOhswYQcrGsQUy7hiw3qU lJyDsOCuQ8AUxB8qHBQ9Eh4jSk0Pfgdk0/KHa8bshkbexQBq5zjQXFb6zSaSPPeJsJ3t1o68 shVV3DjX7msMP5tTvHPbM841OHxl2UIN/Lixw7tYDhXKOdshd3k3KuDZSv57vY2US5g437hh kYcYtz+EvP10ufJR/DM1ed4gozqQLMZcYR4DgzeB6q2f02paNSfOhEYliUmEHKV50tbIo3l7 1FiLRAeu/IHAupKpwjnud3XgFpwl38IROQLgUB0uf5bksGu10TUAEQEAAYkCPAQYAQoAJhYh BDXNdMJKmxWhnhqBoZQ3OqlLfDIjBQJblYJ6AhsMBQkB49aAAAoJEJQ3OqlLfDIj5z4QALaX P1KME/Eru5D4giAuflIzI7zQh2Hx+fOWwTL3fld8Cpkr3qpc8YD8aesL/y1Brrhj0cUHZsjq 3W7CdrjGj+bvNlycaGuBicpaODVcZDdn7wgvGJYmzkcgE5wWFRUCVrPPc+Q6LQNEVNyXyTQf qFikL7Cpt5q/vGvAyNxGOOTkK+hJXXRdwT4PrBS9ve9h+B+zf5dcd8mfRgQlQNjK/SEzVJpr qL7IS0dhIO1bTFLvMHz92M9MEiUz43PLKCtplF3gE++U6gcXMpWIZR/nf0Dx81lBMvWA4B8y eXuXjZW7oXa3sDrZ8tBTQ+UApHV/LCf9JUM8YA7eFL1O2KHGQKPURKeVvVBpkqSGBZj8kCqO XiGvlZCkzQTSRX0zr/j2uhaz3YjuflS94yYWDZ36Lc/pa24BHf+I+4ZW+kimoyi9VWmVYgBV iCDRs24S+++g+9wcRZ6TKYOvCW3mid5YFcOpwba1VZsPH6VBLT576KKg08rDTBixMTK6AAhb OeWcURa7bU5Q98wcexHbEfTxA0Bw6nplAW8IAksuaFjiScqJfJc9fSsjIbCArFoLkNgegpMJ BCWns156d8659oUmWZi01k3cwrDPQmOhvEqSDpVuAMK/ecLFUt+eZAABN/YD9MtDnEAwRE9U 3dS22OFRyBCGmZwuAQQD17UAc7YnwBGDuQINBFuVgrgBEADS9Y8DkhZWadmRRSJFr9z7UsNP 0GC3M9449dhWDq/cYkHKycK1t9cqDMd+cy59QdQBoZAFnIvMQ+bwzEamQyn5jSTkFU4ZYW/l DZXVqeyFCWFOFA9WXNj2Av5RtNZoL7zPLkVztNKxHIheKOx8w5XgFv/MDj1wVHMzQ5zLnCQv 6RbKslfAFIrzy2u2wW91yZ20Oqxjgku5jw8D1/cztkGa+g9a47E9jZSmUE+Nxo4hd7Vn09Qw K8wi86sQKwyCgrL3MugUoLIuiJuctF7MlmqkSKnGDKjgZSX9p64+bFqBUK+T9WEvY0abs6FX dsmMjp9T/N89pMmqvvBxu+XaVU//esApjI49az1jPOkh08UjlmtTN06KZhx6appub2tJZiNw NQDfBKtC572w1bXiHg0knyCRmwXubXtSs3bRiSY8WDRGkQa6nxky368tJ767KQvMD3Ck9gqd xrcBldPgN1bcFmSeNvQX7RA1arQzYuM+gdIUzborEYS6oFWygFNjwUIDiQzVrjiKodgWQIR+ 5MrNcU5Zw8edpDDPsYCO5yhPjVEpMtWXL7aAGUFSs+yXqj06HHSrK83I/BXaImpo1HRlCrIc Ktrbn3goAW9e3+VivWgElvvRs13/NZic7N+JjqaNfLKfPRS4oRkwVHD1kqZQ72iyXO6vtMCn DVJQBAcmPwARAQABiQRyBBgBCgAmFiEENc10wkqbFaGeGoGhlDc6qUt8MiMFAluVgrgCGwIF CQHj1oACQAkQlDc6qUt8MiPBdCAEGQEKAB0WIQSqGlmSKghzjSNCvAVNkqfkq3PsVAUCW5WC uAAKCRBNkqfkq3PsVPmaEADJL4Qsjt45hDStlhWrECSWcNdPws1klQybZ7mvjip3ChEr/6vX pDUrWvonUT70uUksC/1IMdIf/n4U/YYZDLznA4/mFfzD0sEhhQ+UzSsUV0su8uhexpY0D5uG ZC4YgVy8+CTAo0PHQV1VzEu7bbUJIqGQbum4rNUp3A0fuZJgcN0/m8z56uCCU+AWbtOThLu6 15LbIJiBNuE2ruA7fvedxAEyMAL0aSiRQIqV8iuIqWb2d1Aa6I1R3Ze0JYUotJNHkViSlhJH 1xpWurPjGWZMb2YGFI/sYbOdYvmnzvjEPT8EPgCzK8FhPkwzmUXY4X9UTZuzZQl04ajjkTd2 wt/+oHHDp9+4RlMv4259Tc3LC3CTiK9A0kyGs6VwS8r4L3f9t3r/Dp0gPXZYi4PEOFph98l5 +VFpaCI+BNIskgaKcrgp+VhjjtL80Xryw4euYaBc7TkijdaKzdk8Y1pn1tHKtgUiWMnoJq/6 zpwEntNFK86+PUzbuolPsloMx/BeQueEjFgAnRTWbq3hD9tu3plg2CfN0dicVzrzkchDqQqI N/mbpba+VXX6RZzbfYhcRwevmYb9eHmNFyLsjJotUK49yuhPCu7hdriWBpRT1tVI26HEB8OJ ZPZqnR/drMwOZNgnnyL+F00XvbbXEBJzgPM8mBlFJEw5/JQCnsXoJXJx2Ki9D/4jYWlXSTva Ux/gjT8noe8b24NJZcbOcNOj5UeRi1+D30uCWvTALaltnLgr4wBhkjLQ0AkszFrIaCwXMsvS rvcwCfoeOuO+4fnrHPpLT+gLShbY3TFXyOLXrpEDTKVbJ5DMAUjGynQuzPrsvJg46BZxsXRN bjC5qcazAcUsVs6zE7erX5+r4K52YWTNz9BPCDZ20BnUroyVjNfAngVQbVLvpvubjexLVg9Y HRkH8WKDMjFZU3FRww+blRQEhl0vdqYU0TNKgCWYE3RrvaS/F6/LzGTJSVr4B7eLZDqibE1r M1qjvrhqoLyIGpG2M1A0GfwmRoRlVs7ltoV8ZhnGwUSiQmKpuqhAGON9i/IWFL5ncAl9wfAW CCFprkVBqqFxgnB34bP9FtCu5sKeGf2+NbvqhQGaaY9kBIyouK7Pn3f//PXUxOm5vTXFkBV4 mZh1CU0y23/3G6SSdxr6WAIRUdrPD4HhDAKxxG275TsyGnTHYQ6shybdAWHcC5FoAohjTBPJ +8MYotKp3qoQBHQ2Z5BZrO4i/dgR44U1QdBL3CEjFRc9Evvi/bFpbQSdGY2p4Wx6zUqVj9b3 MhfambCS1hIZ3MzFFPlVbfcKFLbTp1op5aUM0s+R7fEgS1UkpRKoSmd+lxq7V3H43fPVoBiI iMVqRRL3IFUR+1BN4zqS9YSh6g==
- Delivered-to: archiver@xxxxxxxx
- Delivery-date: Tue, 26 Feb 2019 09:19:55 -0500
- In-reply-to: <639cbe9c-0814-9fd2-6a13-8f09140bb898@torproject.org>
- List-archive: <http://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-dev/>
- List-help: <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=help>
- List-id: discussion regarding Tor development <tor-dev.lists.torproject.org>
- List-post: <mailto:tor-dev@lists.torproject.org>
- List-subscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev>, <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=subscribe>
- List-unsubscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/options/tor-dev>, <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=unsubscribe>
- Openpgp: preference=signencrypt
- References: <639cbe9c-0814-9fd2-6a13-8f09140bb898@torproject.org>
- Reply-to: tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Sender: "tor-dev" <tor-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Cecylia Bocovich:
> Hi,
>
> I just had a really great conversation with some of the developers at
> Briar about the recent work they've done in integrating some pluggable
> transports into their messaging application. I thought I would summarize
> some key points from the conversation here. In particular, this
> information might prove useful for both the metrics and anti-censorship
> teams to know how other projects are using our tools and what they would
> like help with.
Thanks, that's really helpful. FWIW, I think this information is not
only useful for the teams you mentioned but as well for teams that
actually want to implement respective user-facing changes, like the
applications team.
We had a bunch of conversations in the past about how to make sure Tor
Browser is helping the user to choose a proper and secure way of
connecting to the Tor network depending on their location and context.
Some useful tickets, showing where we are and what we think/thought, are:
https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/21951
https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/24527
Those are mostly related to desktop as we have a Tor Launcher there.
I opened a ticket (#29590) to track the mobile specific part, though.
[snip]
> IV. What they want help with
>
> Because they do not have dedicated anti-censorship funding, they
> mentioned a few things that would help them maintain their pluggable
> transport use going forward and ease the integration of pluggable
> transports.
>
> The main thing they would like on the metrics side is up-to-date
> information about which PT works in which country and where PTs are
> needed at all in order to make quick and easy decisions based on
> location about which transports to use. They started to work with OONI
> to expand their tests but it turned out to be too much work for their
> time/funding: https://code.briarproject.org/briar/briar/issues/1414
>
> It's on our roadmap to work with OONI and other censorship measurement
> tools (like Censored Planet) to expand our tests so we should get into
> contact with them again once we have gotten farther with this.
>
> On the PT development side, they expressed a desire to transfer
> maintenance of their reproducible builds of obfs4 and meek to someone
> else (that's the go-reproducer code linked above).
I think we should be able to provide that with our Tor Browser builds
once we have all the PT pieces sorted out (which is rather soon). So,
probably the easiest way would then be to just copy the respective
binaries we produce over to include them in the Briar software and
pointing to our build process (we could even document building those PTs
as an example in our READMEs if that would be useful). Would that work,
Michael? Or do you need something else here?
Georg
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________
tor-dev mailing list
tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev