[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
Re: [tor-dev] Onion Service v2 Deprecation Timeline
- To: tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Subject: Re: [tor-dev] Onion Service v2 Deprecation Timeline
- From: Georg Koppen <gk@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Tue, 16 Jun 2020 09:15:46 +0000
- Autocrypt: addr=gk@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= mQINBFH3/woBEADHs/Q4t69Vm+mNMW0vH0Ms6HtjpzBsto/yyDAoLitmAxfMIeCuWuyuBdHR krdq9Rk5WQLYtP9eROGkuABK/UaxpLw8zkwkmqbxQ2wxytVwgonOmAFPXvPjzVy+ToJvKWJj tRGFoWwO9OEZ8q6xhVnwLUJXRQF01/XhBhU2RPzzUTHrgiY2bi6Ko34nSM8qAuidykqd/elI wE+kn4+TZ+yBC7pzwUfRK0bOqc05qtq5ooH7rYGpvdOkt9DuoFEjhLrBaL3UiP5J6D9W1Ltv 7Y239RGZyGr0wO5ClhuJwipnw6yWDt493cw4fOy7J1Lbo8dZyU4pnFIgt1Cu506/CvdQ53pR UHhCSIS/IyOiEL9PI/PPByG9UhwNQYk9U22h4MalPwa+4rZ1XA6mf5+T4QQRmghAnegPwyQw qnQzHc2ZPAal+Ill15AncyfIeMfuCLyA/TVWwQTQMzdcVwu3nljBfGOjOSTHOafBqsVlvgEo R9GB9OaTbriP7lCDJmBsgFFZ5F0m6us2pP72TpM0GMYCae7PHk7POhvcE5VJg03E3tjyQUQA zt5ZcpzjZtbcWIoYjxEJMq1Wzj0PYfZYFYZGq2lQx7xJ54gb+RlXEaKiXhDQH+EkrKZHBDWi atMbfkMWiknmn8O7VkuT4LOHsF1I9oJt1VTZ0dx2MVvk2hhs3QARAQABtCBHZW9yZyBLb3Bw ZW4gPGdrQHRvcnByb2plY3Qub3JnPokCOgQTAQgAJAIbAwULCQgHAwUVCgkICwUWAwIBAAIe AQIXgAUCUuzzUQIZAQAKCRCUNzqpS3wyI694D/90P74XiDzioGbNEH37W9P5G6unLUKp/zLf 5Ifosf6ijS5EvhKXpSXAqWu4eSpUh+i72Kr53SvzAIggWjUM61e92xt0bg4+VFaguMh6d9l0 MpDMfRJB+qoRNaDDyGk1VH9ZLBJOpTY59HcIIyg2LIMt1PHk+3npr0MnDfh/5fgyPvFRv9ZK WkKdwD4ImlqGXaxsES2pPk8tn21k7J4N8jzRAYM8oV9cMeeCbMgERilU2sRxNORs55zV6GiD A68lmwY6+OHjaKd0k+Oibs63PrTl1+P4EYBZTlXK9gSSWKiUydVP+2lQoyGVmuH0VpepEcnv zu06g+YU4TiH3f7t1chknGlEm1s872nyZo7Nd+zVDcIa4iklBMpeEsPDB6zRT7KBH+oCw5vK G+Ngjv3AO8hD2RTFHw8oAD8WPBbrOB2C9qSha/XSl7rjxTpqRillP+543xhQncC3b2x+Vk4C wlJdrjOvweMnM4xCEeg03WUeRz6a4Uuh6A9x4WZia+5Y5PrKG4GKPeBbskFdw6N0/10Gk1nF wpS42esKsrvqeltRLPzwFj0FEO+mole3y2f+iR8rJd/rik7AW9PM2YkhiF8kmcyh07GSjcCo qg7AkOJ87Bv2knZ0KYlukY5wBKK/DY55GTLGQ7w6kR/BzMOlKnru1e0+zvyZ4KijODEuaUi1 2bkCDQRdd2fNARAA129/1tcgz/gZRL9duwIxRlrN9VPMGHXs9WPjIIhbZ2xe6jN/ZwuyLIrq fM8MyzMkJYY9oDK6PhzpYkgMt7Z+s/rkFwOduxya4apwOI/gDZ//+eNiKSnXr5KA9rBjk7OF ZWEdT2/Y1u1s84o5SKVEH+N/C0Hum/CNawdldvxaviiF4DxGXi57NUIiI9dW1Gv2Mk7cCHwR Hew6BLLYUC0UyB/0qsZmVpxsu2P22wc0f5DU3ijVBOKlIWy4J49cR57glTB7KqbtZTaCSQpv 9SqamvP/BVyRg1Gk4OLPAC+kxzOWcosWThAUK7T3nlSxKEygQhZmT855l0J/fmsx0zqLL5gW 0vSV7hl6EIShhXUxIY7SZjKkPdzAdCHhAERRq4l2y41k8XEdXo8nYs2j8JaV/NFvM+h7DQOs IRExr7Kshp0gae3k6ZzhWHnm8E+iJKAOmagh43iYZFHb3c10Xg4XRjNoyxETQporYsSIkIzl 8VbtqywFqxfahxWWprePUyQhNhdb7+Xg4B2oAZcIzy15KVLtwgdopcob9KreO7nRFtlu+Wrt msnkkOqzce/XZ62PyFsRtQeaLGxwUSXBzCnpieOpRZWdx5F+c48PzEJoQxRPRbe9gXFaeRtZ erIDv/e8YLYlSkkKNkINGtxo9Olqu3/MzN2R22iCHvQNzh951XUAEQEAAYkCPAQYAQoAJhYh BDXNdMJKmxWhnhqBoZQ3OqlLfDIjBQJdd2fNAhsMBQkB49aAAAoJEJQ3OqlLfDIjQpIP/AlW NB1XFkzPB54vzoXsw9B6j0+4h6KMZKpqi06uATF34j2JMWv+xKhHsSlK3apltjX04VAhhAxQ lc3yfG2B3PfKH/Rw97/NEphNjsgqkwpGs5XWMrXlu+rIObz6rKYHtZ3wePxcGWGOizZ/yfZz Swh6iqjWEo7Q4aF0fQchAa4FY6+emg0nX9lvJMjLYXZcntz4pQ8jHLAsT9H8AH5yOT0BMjgP u72xZ9F77TdFoaoQ2LiBI/BKiN5WuLOP9NzowokRlOdUtC0kDwUzcv6LpR1qHq4d2kXssJUr 7mfVS0+EuT3XQWpNaInbiXgHcPn1C/GbqlTXDFICE5hxM081EpzEbRdneyFlInRNYMOKsiP0 7gEzm6LCG5ZK5xydVS4vCwENBDjYQQe5JpLEvLok3shud35R32muCZpDyJrYMbHQTpJ6pODO +LS1RaK/derXGylK/OT5IxQaAszM8wAMFQvQi+hGAOvF/vCvZ++so34aB258mJIFz7XKJPFO Bgfeqcz9YvrUwl6ZoQmK9t5fzYI3hRuUmRHUBBG3gBARvDTb32f//FEJfJ5nioaMClXw4Hoc jf+0Xa1DYJn/2Utjwr7HHQI6tLMDdI5VNc2L8V2axFjmmV3Sb3pQo1eT1bcNgjyuCht/WYEq CJvi1mOQRh0UKS/WV70ni0jQjlmn53ubuQINBF13aDEBEACwlExNzqrcYFVzkpWC8XKW0E14 sbecwjZGRTU7Eq0aZytEgRvG4ijAz3Bn9Z/tMTdL5a2GzGHhRx1oC9HXAGr5q9Zqz/B2Qyfn slnDN/cO6cKk5hnbIjQuPi5Eg5+oGeKGhClrRbI9OOuK0lm9tlUnAxkdOgmGz1t5FL6F+gWY M8Pam/kvvKJfqmPBtmsqSKW7ERGPZ27jqP7YddfB89UaDF4lsMkX3WTGe1gyL1CU2uFU9L93 FhxPDcUUzSntDjlVau2E7Px5sunnxVUZzM8kuCAJMg0LQ+AfNfrr0L8fOe2Z2cvkDr+efS0f VyA5+wv8svEuiRqY4Rrp5qNDiAvxAzO3y0c6gw9iYYqNnfQ7XbuiW+9Tuhcb+h1DJnR8b4YD VPMrfuga92Y3vdSNo+l3eelcvcGSxmSSZSgdqEZOmr4mJOZmXPNJUzMcdaX4jb1mg26TpntK OkR556Uot4kwfaP0m/aNqlRYergxvjXB7DYBDxWGmcDMnotfEBnTtihSWJruM56p5yddNjiw gbm07jWyJC0kI/r399KgBVXsSqKTDRpagwk3/zbYkIA2/NsENCQxp5zu6BJXdrT6Dy6F36Bc NlodzLRHGmqblZ4zCxoKnE7lmhJjr+mZzsWadyg5HRPDlQYATu4HEsbVYY590G2L9b6volHE 2Rc+T1diJQARAQABiQRyBBgBCgAmFiEENc10wkqbFaGeGoGhlDc6qUt8MiMFAl13aDECGwIF CQHj1oACQAkQlDc6qUt8MiPBdCAEGQEKAB0WIQTUttOn/VUPhD4MgOd+Q4tauRcwPgUCXXdo MQAKCRB+Q4tauRcwPh7/EACpcfyUg3rCO+YC5TO528m2aYLYlEmSsSsf/IFfst1jde0L+yuC klQIvvrylbUCutlG65CktxOAfig6o8DNfO/j4m7PADg1m5tALFKp8yWgUemv7NKc8Jl/3fM0 cgjBY+pu82QKcEmFcY9gt+C0gH5lmfBHdTKdycYJ/7TCbYgoLworKG58g9pNqiYkkBSQY2q/ XywoPrbyhRrsOmcty/uumOnpu9InDKjBxE/c3HmWTTxqr8T5caKrQdNXWkSjv5FzRQC95Ymi oQeorRnWDNSJ4UcmEohvs2m+9uWAPIMgcBKefVsKWxKK0CvZLq/tpjw8bgkpRqHL7fWXwwIF 9jH04psmfiom8pzS0fxqaVmBVUHj0PMqIimg74fUmoeJmhTR18rp+hdB3xPeX7Rq6c6Y8JDI kA7WSLx+kptHQ58YOAg3r14FoRR8mp94gDiEyQwj3bME9laBLSYKWjdkW99M5/BXU/MgaK5Q uQ0V2Dpfr753lnne+u44SS5AMc+WUVvvcwM5WdjdPrioSOotJoZGuGEU63WEHhAPb2DaEa0Z poXZIvFu14V5+0AHLgo5qsJMu2sWDO72kgx/f5bGZgpg0ubivgTmWxtB/1r4+ochKDyAJhol ZzonlhpiOLuve8lDjf2j6u2ztuKcHGDoc3LPuS8n5/KZ1FnNmplpM0TNnmcUD/9g8G2Aj4ah nUB5DJiPab2EZaoe6eufn1slNcPHAhBZyjftOM8iQ58i5HygrG48M9/zF5VQ55kc8etGN6cB L9XXrqZTcB354BcXLjrYe/1Atm3x+OI392WUi22N/BYzmMUDaB0vxh3wDO379TyoC9MAOY41 oG4YddBYQqHS1kO/CjCUlWGaG1qksowSgS1P6mn+6ZF7y90yphvo2CF/9L/eI9UsqLGfywji 97qXwBY6a38Ya2TrHlA/Qn0vepf6aSieV1SlDpFOGfeS1/tkKJgsRFZb91iI4Qz7Mex+dQQn iiG42+OwllkKFmE78MrjrspBON4FTFtrAXKGmPZqHPWFHUmSZAowX6XHK/GaEDX5y8KMcAje annxvwSUEtDtkbw4Zkx/s0uJvY2DisXjui6IybnocBp6GUSnhQRfU8kROkW3oVQ7qGNcqESU WFsBVKu+4s1fMa1KrYVwqG2zQZLQVQucIFPZFUUoEecTqaBLuQn8gxcuDMDo4x7l3KnayHdK t/PQWA08IW+NVgiRB8Nzjtbar1emzlwYd/KCkqoI4OpK+lzpjjijsvrzErTWN4jHTFk8v3pm RwN6Nq/n+uuSh7l66ZzGsI3tkw6TB365bOapmwH+QfcI40MVe0cizdqcCgyL/yyEcz0MZgoS /3KOe0GZ1A2SWewkOuVBNQF6dw==
- Delivered-to: archiver@xxxxxxxx
- Delivery-date: Tue, 16 Jun 2020 05:16:11 -0400
- In-reply-to: <20200616083102.GB2640@moria.seul.org>
- List-archive: <http://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-dev/>
- List-help: <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=help>
- List-id: discussion regarding Tor development <tor-dev.lists.torproject.org>
- List-post: <mailto:tor-dev@lists.torproject.org>
- List-subscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev>, <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=subscribe>
- List-unsubscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/options/tor-dev>, <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=unsubscribe>
- References: <20200615163417.g4wbevnf5hyy3xwb@raoul> <20200616083102.GB2640@moria.seul.org>
- Reply-to: tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Sender: "tor-dev" <tor-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Roger Dingledine:
> On Mon, Jun 15, 2020 at 12:34:17PM -0400, David Goulet wrote:
>> 1) September 15th, 2020
>> 0.4.4.x: Tor will start warning onion service operators and clients that
>> v2 is deprecated and will be obsolete in version 0.4.6
>
> Thanks David. "Late 2020" is also a good timeframe for Tor Browser to
> learn how to warn users when they visit a v2 onion service.
>
> That is, we can't just change the underlying Tor proxy program to write
> warnings in a log file. We need to improve the user flow for popular
> Tor-using apps, starting with Tor Browser and maybe continuing to other
> common Tor-using apps we appreciate such as Brave.
>
> I recognize that the Tor Browser dev team has their hands full with
> keeping up with Mozilla's changes while trying to improve things for
> mobile while having not enough funded developers for those tasks. All
> the more reason to highlight this need early, and to do as much of the
> supporting design/planning/strategy work as we can in other teams like
> the UX team.
I just Created
https://gitlab.torproject.org/tpo/applications/tor-browser/-/issues/40001
(via email, yes, you don't need to click around anymore in a GUI to do
this kind of thing ;)).
Georg
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________
tor-dev mailing list
tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev