[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
Re: [tor-dev] Tor Bandwidth List Format specification
- To: tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Subject: Re: [tor-dev] Tor Bandwidth List Format specification
- From: juga <juga@xxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Thu, 10 May 2018 13:40:00 +0000
- Autocrypt: addr=juga@xxxxxxxxxx; keydata= xsFNBFONpUkBEADCZKJs2sXSK2qEvIquZKnt16LCsg61kacKX9MGdbrfB/xxrjx9tcU6fCFd C5//4OwI+sT/E41LrwpV8cehVtoAtmwyUK+/LC3XLbK8m8XSp8/ghOBnm2jlI0z9FVqfHuiv cfd6v7C2xSkqu2TvzdavBetHgPtJwrZ1zK5suQY4ww+48C2GvyqwJR1CMjJq2mz5CEa3mh7N vwqnSxM8Oh1ptSiRbkGR36GF5rt2w2fbFv143fqvquNi+T0P/VWjFk7DZA4d6yhiiM3zb3IL I3TOlgZT2oyjAqq5DTU5evS1VYq9zugT5xvvFQ473M2le3uSr5wPhj4kXkDAgbaHOxinBfR4 ldT3yDJ63mDq1nxxhBfoDx6EP/8gard04aow1zFw8USUS18wloV5/XMnGZX4vYFpKfPYxOSw CFyXXPxGkeIqZ7A1kuUJnvnsfFs+FzPor0EkaKHV88HB/XFwupgc1h4EhmDcEAQJGh8wgjrN A/xLH6tiv08VSC6wtS1BfOQsaRoA32/rQAusoZ5uzwk1C4WJlJ6RkBf/XWIFt9T+22gl8rAP 6MGTFGzq1Wnvfp54ih16+B3tyrH1rjfo2TSHzJypdOJElhjxi2RxLGD3UBOrmjm2nxqWYEE/ syQRWaTs7UTXQ83veLs0exIKzr31nUHuYIqkCITPHVTywHJ4FwARAQABzRIgPGp1Z2FAcmlz ZXVwLm5ldD7CwZcEEwEKAEECGwMFCwkIBwMFFQoJCAsFFgMCAQACHgECF4ACGQEWIQQtqB0B RVw6ADIZiFDzBUR6+AbUawUCWT+5lAUJB5NHywAKCRDzBUR6+AbUa29FEACTIHcWwDSMacME vYiFBcXPYeA+vHvg8Tn0D/utUsVimmwSZTai9pyFXo7cvAZV99VgWgqv8hGg4YqGu/NJdnCD VMeJt/y9zE7qvfqpI9vxOr6BNzhbg0ww61oPqSvyfb68muFiwMvfl7my3pkYqoHlngfcjoMI qZuhxG/UHl2jNIYYlRIhA3mR1lCp2BmZjKUcWlTPN70WDWTfRjjnGLFgi6ce5uM7egxFPo5c 69t4t8mRVFkBN58sdfwfQ1FWZLlAw6yc8NIkj3/mHPHnH1ihBbAGWRB66wlfm5ZCrFxdOxg8 43KHXf92d5rgvs1R4ap2NzibMJL/Hlty0cDgvvhBDeJ87EPikMOl5GT1kqQKRPLdrz0J2rus y8UFIlFot//ekhmxFZp3MnKxzG6xs+Ok3D5tbHCyS+c4WMIjDTaNFUMRxzjXy9mIneQ7DSDV wsEtiftl6SKdRulLjIDhUwEIXZvoeYLThhd/dsYTth+6RAfi88eUqGnjYI3YkfAw65lz9AwN PoyUXoSVeANEhad/GbpnfBGA/o4cntQNk5jS5nQdPwSTLqZCKGGOuHW1UKpHz8A8wrrt36gl GihSJuKhtpsQYKv+7SUBnrXkHzBtspLH7MK9Svf3IZFOgUzIHtKAOVsVFhEfClq5LGz8cpfB 3qyv5EhQ1QRpFOiN4c3Ays7BTQRTjaaBARAA5UBd7mTMdO/6wXKSfeJef5Wwtuc8Js4zdZOM uZ15Kkqk5P3wALqUVzrSsdDv4vO2M79ZranbHWcdAOApkRiRJ0Yu/fzUdgyBBf6v4KI98sZD LRdz/I+7994sAgB839dd+hTKQDuG7rArKxD3PWYLkaWRkOX/rPJUJ2l5xeF69kSrtyANfXPs mvZjzDBBvxegelYAGroDHXUJjgMSXPIz3nLVwQtJTMszs7tyOW+/Nhb6+SPilzahGWWd39Cs wbo0CoKu/AjAcdeNbcS3ab4fNy/yARq2EXFB5+vTSkAolDoDBriGqGpCDgvoFPz7lb7/IGld jsO8MQddlztu38X/Md3fGu4Cje/IchqfNb8eikztVxyVImtc1MXUWs4Ecc2t5FYmVzlTXppI tA/rpM9D4w/QEnyptQ7Uu8aItTOmy3NEHUGR/pWH2J0M78zrAg1FP6Dso4ANRVM2wTsQbeys 8e0NHocGUI64MS/2Xqmkd+bEdFY8RdoNzakUcai1VnDobYMbp9c37K+WjeBVsru5JqEkjzfv u8Zk7Ji0f4EyZ4ng+JlMsldytE5LCO0nEduJYCWpa3FtuEy7P9zK0kThq6ED3I3b2JtboADt c0I1tpZto8A21JN60ULUJbyGA/UqZFAqJu8qBUI8nrqAm/5nyv/e6axeZl3vJfmGcskHqI0A EQEAAcLBfAQYAQoAJgIbDBYhBC2oHQFFXDoAMhmIUPMFRHr4BtRrBQJZP7mkBQkHk0ajAAoJ EPMFRHr4BtRrppIP/3DS3og9FiY3VB7a1LLbthGEj3e/ORrPxpQicwSB/Rn70KsrVtB5AYaH bcD64yJCxHLaxKOXNoLtNvAqUHGiJxCN9QNElRlQG+DsuglsUSPAAjgGbGueaB6VFoGv5QZY xkc3K7t7K/Q0V87wUZmxFPAGZK5KMud8Zy93s+U9i2bdXEQsANGb4ubT7rfYGU0TGio+zRMY 1vEokRMz87hyM4laFwwa2X+JrcSl0Ghg382IDJG6lK2DsVU5M1TkqBC0/vmnfOx+/OFuMsWo dCB/vmOEiuH4xM5/c856OPsPz0SYhlGfLqrpr51lp2tAG19JuZCQ/uPZqt0KYuebk0nhnOS8 PFujQiYhSebXyLfcUBXUEu0BMqjWPE0Yumk/2zluq10t4xZDjGvifcH/1AzxPlH6ezxote8H OjiL+pOYSqbHoEGFNX95wMinU7niq75r1ikonsMKKgQDP1Tl06TKenwH6Muci/FX9Q2YhHJ1 uEODG0kFr/LqIFMdj9mUtAH20p1weyhGG+X6BUIjc96XTbaLms43qT0RI/cil1PQBrRzS2S0 OjT6j+g5WkKOS17MEFnar7lOcQvxD62hSuD4HKZ1WL0ocExRxReSFfjFXWaibHNyhNynR4pQ FNMJrVJl5qqdXi9u89gq5wSWTb3t5V00CsPP0e0jBSgh6jT5xUil
- Delivered-to: archiver@xxxxxxxx
- Delivery-date: Thu, 10 May 2018 10:18:31 -0400
- Dkim-signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/simple; d=riseup.net; s=squak; t=1525959632; bh=bYcUTGO+NkiCl0Y0gMMSy+NWk3aAq+qHkNvijZ8ilCw=; h=Subject:To:References:From:Date:In-Reply-To:From; b=bcxTLF5X2Etn7ehLbIjIwm0RwEU6k4WeS6cASCriBn7s7JwCER3UVXtJyaZffs0Xo jpNza2tJnaNz+3vBwKh+TCj5e1OcdtUWQ0AzVL8WhDqeSgftldEkITT8UNFiTAPfM0 vlBnx1zgIDEW58GvSGYb8bZzHc3MNXEaQp1UCmPA=
- In-reply-to: <1cfd35d6-a496-384b-b7c4-8f940fd070c8@torproject.org>
- List-archive: <http://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-dev/>
- List-help: <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=help>
- List-id: discussion regarding Tor development <tor-dev.lists.torproject.org>
- List-post: <mailto:tor-dev@lists.torproject.org>
- List-subscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev>, <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=subscribe>
- List-unsubscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/options/tor-dev>, <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=unsubscribe>
- Openpgp: preference=signencrypt
- References: <3d78d51e-ccd4-cbe0-0acc-1a5f99294c3d@riseup.net> <1cfd35d6-a496-384b-b7c4-8f940fd070c8@torproject.org>
- Reply-to: tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Sender: "tor-dev" <tor-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Iain Learmonth:
>
>> The main question that came up was whether we should create a backwards
>> incompatible specification version 2.0.0.
>
> I do think it may be easier to finish this specification first before
> moving on to a 2.0.0 version. We discussed this specification at the
> last Tor Metrics meeting: Currently Tor Metrics' descriptor parsing
> library (metrics-lib) does not have a parser for the current (1.0.0)
> bandwidth lists. We should implement this, and hopefully it would not be
> too much extra work to make this also work for 1.1.0 lists.
It shouldn't be much extra work, if metrics-lib ignore the extra header
lines and extra bandwidth KeyValue (as Tor currently does).
>
> If there were to be a 2.0.0 version, I would hope this brings the syntax
> closer to other Tor descriptors to enable us to reuse existing code in
> our parser (and also for tor to reuse existing code too) rather than
> being something entirely new.
That was the idea :)
Thanks!
juga.
_______________________________________________
tor-dev mailing list
tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev