[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
[tor-relays] Re: Tor Relay Deployment Dilemma: When to Not Pay for Underutilized Server Resources?
- To: Tor at 1AEO via tor-relays <tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Subject: [tor-relays] Re: Tor Relay Deployment Dilemma: When to Not Pay for Underutilized Server Resources?
- From: Felix via tor-relays <tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Sat, 5 Apr 2025 22:03:23 +0200
- Cc: Tor at 1AEO <tor@xxxxxxxx>
- In-reply-to: <MeAFBfEKacepgWeuqjKvYnsobcZLcZEMtbcb9zTW8-tmiRffEGUftGxtk2HjGsJjXh-04K0Jq4YlA1J3o2E_Wf6-fQJmECs2d88HkgjRc3Q=@1aeo.com>
- List-id: "support and questions about running Tor relays (exit, non-exit, bridge)" <tor-relays.lists.torproject.org>
- References: <MeAFBfEKacepgWeuqjKvYnsobcZLcZEMtbcb9zTW8-tmiRffEGUftGxtk2HjGsJjXh-04K0Jq4YlA1J3o2E_Wf6-fQJmECs2d88HkgjRc3Q=@1aeo.com>
- Reply-to: Felix <zwiebel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Ui-outboundreport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:3ve2XWtIKtw=;x9fW+rDS7NQKp6nOGQu2WIvkbVT iWNX34zdnc4FMmhie/moqz1MDTg118h9VBg3/yge/U1KHi1iRVOgWUbYI69aABtaC4J2+NBae S81lHHnKd0E5T/UXp0DoiKsPE2sGV6jjIwVpVm4iQAFP1jedz51mbjt0b88zp+F+I07He/mab 0NS5gI8tUQHVsFp8SpE3m0+IAuXu8FnQ5x6sUgi0uqt6nZ3aqF33oi+PYAuFgXVFqc2ZTvsLI R2Zz/KVz+9NNtm+IfCTG6VT76HmZByTE5yiAQIfUAAHQO/P+c9UOgxyox24m9OdXXMH0d3o10 hU6eBNnjOUZMwCs83QQLYRnsjhxqaG5e0kgzTzSQQbY6VtnW9Q4KxL4QqbY/bB2N8KX5uaPTW +i49khoRcvxXhktwezyZ1Q7oVkcWPAzxyNjj6tHkAkx5Mzy2RNr6tV9m67nm7CrmgQdMn7S/Y lmsHCBmdbofoQKLFV6HmSECGggL7ODJaMKs2yFBNo/tF6v4I6S1u++fDgrhmGinPYoXBxiDaJ sj46b6sw85JwpSv0DWieJ8M789L9x+7IUImaAJM6s8eYOEN2jg4f0xkyX7Efe69SZxfk39s9I cp76GDslyNXxUUqQnTAXousP0ta7I1q1b93ROhtp75gdhcEqybe4dBYq4vKdHQQAraaNAXAZJ 9swIX7qymqETHkp94N4ElTVZVqtf7cFWVKdUUAsdoixpmCOMj7lv/bAmkuOJ87ZKCS8Tam9WX /ow6h77pNcTZ7AEfTTHgqeM4ThhXK97oQCl6cblgfKB+zFnv071/n+htdQ7yP3P7qPQy9v3R8 0n4q6OTlrQoaJfx0WL2a15+BXcyvPisuXX3xz3OTFyT/3qdZRj+HqOz867iGuYPCVt4xQML0U SzYs+Ezh2h8iNuPPr2F0hwArAZVY4+bdstHeirxDnj9I3mGpnAxe7yVm5IJ3x+vjShLTi/ArJ MgEeeT0+zC3NrNNuzT/7pJntZRVAtRKAQNeIqBaKIxH5mK/x9T3XPzXrDGkHmGsQj33UQP/lt wv6fgxoqnyAsxk8EgSJvntaYrBhojrbituG28k1XBc2KK6JsrAWqbwJfSK988J04sz+uJO0sf 3cFpMiT65/QPC/8aR58zAbIvCG0mZzCkEVq37USgRrTHcpQCrfF0t8IXeeSMqEgRkuqS6PK7T 1p2lG5tomjQDlLAx9xo/eNTX+N2OlPD0mB0p+sduH4iVAErCm9NV9PigzQJG2mRt1uu7f6Cpv /mWryzNwivJd/QhjRVOaDDXQOx7d/0XPpgADRkXFrloe0317b3BaZE/We6TYpw2ox21QuySNc IlVYYclIP0uG7g+GIUdDaTJIzZA30V+a71xBwtu3vwCtlO1KNcMbjfufodhjowl5wdgKPwyo3 G+mEKmkBz8eRZ/XozvnALnyuHS0uj73TZULOXwyBdCLMszQLG/2mk2/3p9ykZsT3YOsflmY1g UAQ9A9vw6WIbyP9u/fkOvcgap7MQ=
Hi
>> Part 3 - Looking for feedback on our Tor relay configuration
>> decision:
>>
>> Looking for guidance on optimizing server / bandwidth spending for
>> Tor guard / middle relays across datacenters.
> https://metrics.torproject.org/rs.html#search/contact:1aeo
> 2Gbps means 1Gbps in and 1Gbps out.
Thanks for the informations.
>> Overall, using 16 Gbps out of 30 Gbps purchased --
>> roughly half our bandwidth is idle / "wasted"
Is it right that most (all?) relays are not older than mid of March?
If so please take a look at
https://blog.torproject.org/lifecycle-of-a-new-relay/ .
As for as I see the relay status page shows not a single relay with a
HsDir flag and no uptime above 2 days.
Gaining a trustful relay with good traffic needs much more time alive
of the relays (keys). Easily 3 to 6 months.
The relays are on up to date Tor versions 4.8.15 and 4.8.16 what is
good!
My recommendation is to let them brew for 2 months. The situation will
change.
Cheers and happy relaying, Felix
Attachment:
pgp8rmI4_wjvM.pgp
Description: Digitale Signatur von OpenPGP
_______________________________________________
tor-relays mailing list -- tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe send an email to tor-relays-leave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx