[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
[tor-relays] Re: confirming onionoo/CollecTor issues vs. Happy Family relay misconfiguration
- To: nusenu via tor-relays <tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Subject: [tor-relays] Re: confirming onionoo/CollecTor issues vs. Happy Family relay misconfiguration
- From: Felix via tor-relays <tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Wed, 29 Apr 2026 21:11:57 +0200
- Cc: Felix <zwiebel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- In-reply-to: <fc9f660a-69d1-416f-80d3-eb7eda93f2f6@riseup.net>
- List-id: "support and questions about running Tor relays (exit, non-exit, bridge)" <tor-relays.lists.torproject.org>
- References: <fc9f660a-69d1-416f-80d3-eb7eda93f2f6@riseup.net>
- Reply-to: "support and questions about running Tor relays (exit, non-exit, bridge)" <tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Ui-outboundreport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:08DDdGYBN3Y=;ci7eOqdB2JamBrRoU58cce34NuZ f+TFPodrJDfoRxLGnKhnI3S+PaWHNGStdiBNddL6JpD6/5G1+ELvzKoyJT4qh7ckB9PH+cFGn bKkQmbDfSL3W6u2OjAVZ0JMklg04BNmpbd7dE1KV974/P1J2oO6SkL91sviIxQn0fLKmT/rt2 QxipxMhwnQbd7DgztYXkGoa3kPCpuFXFfxWZ0JlPV6jrf5H4oCuHSLV/U4sLttPoa3/GEKu5R VZ17mmSTBBNn7sj0j7Q2v6suVwsh2SkLKEzNw9l6xuMKqIeXeYqdS1vibNiMZIYY0ZwJ+i1sR /LGwZ4duJe5od7n2xwXDrXH6+6NhoqNVWl7kcHufTeGXSo2lN9Y+iGPOUw/u5xwRc58KqypyA htCCsae+habnfwSQuGCf53yF2dJEeUPxlydXidMUX6gkWywIim2LM6beFEYKRWAOf95dBUeme 0VWCAZGBBZhK3ZO5wBvWVOABmIYgoP17UoiB/V7Dj5lErzwA2NyRkUH/SdFmQvQkMJ2+dXHwV aPe2g9AqoU9vnL/FOG1l0mnl0BvptoglTli+rXgcu7VmuRwn4NxmqnVPJbStnNl3Ctn2ZI0em KMoh99vE4jTd6Iv5fi2NbMIfAIVYZAWjzDCHkQfQv18d2W4KaBgxzP9lJvInIg0jGZAJTEtmp mue6aGqrfLbNdSSOL1M/NTzpyoaQKgzmfLsHz2dFfFKvPFp3PEhWYXJthTvIIIS9BP9hQh3kd E1alN86xzTj9GDmagG958F2jZ/fdDvI9YEVRIxPydlKg/62eBo1E6KPtXTLPOPWHtk4UbMaMP ogJleTc/KOGDGaehY84PWEzUXDQ+YXX300WrwykQnj3txVbi+Eh4FL4IYnprFWbZ6dGnX+mya I2Pfn/oPtuyXxoUgB2g59YmMOu90csfH4kXjA6RaIO0srAnX5tLbygK07m6ZJ1eNFvScuZv6m Hearu6NA2r3wa9b4NVmqbTwsY5+fnXRIqxqT+iTjmfe4nniWFapAKZJMMoMSUUZ4Vba0lVzrr z9vyr+4xQNpDxWhG04bNwie/RR3d7X+f7ms5kJ2uI37XpGtHSsyF/OMctw467i/+oq39kWOcS Ck3OBRk+i5tCV0+obGfsRUY3yUpwVBjof0cdtlAS9RWvTIPcw0buxj8lVM5fk2xK2w2sOPx89 dhjdtMegXL7iHEhhwRGd+atx128AYmEtvTAqjdxsTe/KmAV9wqg8DNm7wnW9ioZh569CoLSaY KE19C/jOGg87cb2WAYap4/l+a1+9mu9sC8PtBHkZF4H92YZGayQp6Nd6sGYA6pXGkiLejim68 OCeL0+u9XiUStfAdEd9Af7lNEZMAeNK5hXjFrpFs4tGi3Cxo+iGlWkqFHL+gHJgrZHPgWlikz d83i1Wz1/eGzDgCTLD8DkgrSJ1vqQCVhPT+329U84Bse7vI3KTOVABB5xgB8lV5nbIDc5zTxy rHy0xmlgvT3XaMwd34m60W68BcgjvbfFMsC59Vjx2JPySG0lMH/u2hCcjHvOvaiuqlfPTOUCS rroXGkJiCqPgmgPbz0DkzWIXDaHS6gUwelebmtM1pPxyQ0rpM4qYeucQbT1ty7Ylb7Prb+sAU FMLy3y9IacRHhZOLbK6ZzalkVY7jJs4dBRTE8J6Gc9iMolJLYirXrYhws4KWAB2ZpcxncX+Bi /oFYOpbQo10J7ZNkg0YIckNFO3C2Cp2u5WzoNHyrOa0tqfN43wEKYY9XtLUNDKDX5u3UxCJpx cgmPu3/c0217mjmRzWc3435fVgcVVpNlIOiT+TOY2W3sA1Ums7zi38XSFY2A9FtWbly0ZJ+uI 36VH1jLNAvw+1JAH4Kp6xo0mVvg+I92fRZHqRmCqjv2oBDJIGKt1vHRon2qKaS25InGnqOFRG 62EP4bopbGNKMu7KbfMxv0bc/lT3R23Hbb+M8NnDgJ4+VqtkgUN+qp79CQUg2mg8eZxxRXALQ mnyxmyck9C5sydLJ7CynJVr2S42hNfORIaAB4rrzBrQetRsYpaTv0cbdLBFa6sZRCqBPNSibD yuX/TToNNk3VgJaInG7UY2ToSBiJRn+WJFdpKTQIjALWS6tCFqIZeFtPABvYkLcYE5HhBHcZI d93pOcaFlKARCAgkVpGqzDa/QpGcWCJtn59EKe/z8wcbYdAWi8wP/u7q/U4SjWEbgxIOHJwob DTNysTOgrlmRJ+FbzrGMlHsDAXsHS4+F5qXTOOn61qQRqqwlQ/HwOdOaDvAVccody5PM7pVhG S11wFXVugW00IHj0n2fm0wqlcr2bxWIaDgDmidqzoWOs8h3p2ZxIV2ziyK40WMUs4k/60uqYP l/EidvSXv1hVoV+hqEf/CVKQ7Y64Or6Huvw16mG0Z61mMqDuB9uF2ANTmzGAugLPSw2ujVxlc zNtkaHF9+t+hVaH6dSVsJEd7mQ3owq4C7MsIsSgl5A0ZXLbFqu4fl7OqC2uESllUyKZMano54 T5/tY5+4I4dOeSDu5GMdDDEsdEcmWW0SiWB+OZetcCKBGgF1ey3dqKtvznWuQpBHx7O9SrOhP v+vXJTYqLcEDtTMtHAEX2kQwKnNARus00QsAIdf4JcyN1GlfFU4C/TQKco3vAq1AAVHFBR6Fc 1vBWWPXm3fY/WaRqnlmHNCy1xsOeRFzTNdrxkDJXjxitvhXkQFdfSL2jwFQ1aZiUY9NiTVFI5 xt0wyv3tFSzW8Xg1/BGKOeR5nhyYVsTkqCI7gdahHO06YTEzEHDQCLy4OmQeCOKBA9JZSPuBk qo+tgZVlXtkK5RTs6siQ2WUkl5Yey/gkvFpGNlU0E11gQiBKsayFGXHUvERwPbDnrJ3B+dKG5 wo/kJBUCGC2KfTkni2BnGTbumGgYS3dxKAfda33YUqLF+W9PrB9JEbD7WHU+TIrsEtB2AFEP2 CjEv/5mXtmMt/bUiLUXeOt6lO2DDq6VgJfOdZraIPvLnjlO2gHF5/GyW4pMNuzK5Vf7EbVDPP xjPAqpVrKx3YTR0IdPpsItZMu9xpupW4YHduzMHsNIS5Ye6eZ3/umm9+B/UQfzcrnx9DeTGgR 1Kacn5DfRR0Mel46ULzENRXD94kAhlS8HmhWRixWeny5qMwzv0j/I9FRJ813RbgjPU017Us0R 6VvWrL/Xt9zCJh6kkJcL9uWrA4I8/aC0p/RH5eDhTyWrsQXdqPgRTc5hXESLl0rTDtWo0fmix jYnR7SKX0cBRl/YnyKqvbDXabzf9xOSVKhNgoRSufBDNUAArs8J7PlAIiHtzVm1/O9H6p6Cwo wn6tUztxN4Echevn68pu1QlkCzW6Cf1LJayxshOsX3DnKtpf+tF/42F+yPh2EMUH6b8Mue3bl x61y10RkndwOtVG36ny2qmtm0LiFHlTejPImRDHny7VgMXRFfoVWniua3lllXE/aZ9db7/5Ih Uk7kCM8sUx9upXHYZGyASaMg95DN1JDBrgXHz/PQ0kV94aFwCXILJSHCjPXY5/7BuQDf2wUDn nnCr7zJZ/2lmGJ4qiW02UXMJDodNywpPTI1UZq3fY8opRj0ld+z4jwCJCYzBox3d8tD2bE4p6 MwgrKL214uswgrVhi2TROK75afajKAKUOdABEQzGx6HPdPiHS/wfB25tvZUz9QenOFkTSwiCt vWgGZEFakBlOeGtB7KqHpF40AjHX8yq17u54P3TAeqwKk0EQsi+4Wulnks6EuXYLb+81AVFfY Y2JvznWvjKXviX6HWng6HowrKVKd6tRLe2sxwfVNsKsZ4E66F4tZcRbcNuJUieFFykHfUg9Go WEqBupqjfhdPtj4zx+L5YWb4J/sOj19I6IcGpW19k5UDmSXwRGog7eDd87nwoVN80pHCGgn1K 5x98Cz1UpD/EjjeX36pdKuIdTqXTbnfYqiS84Gv9tepb/MviGwkaWT0/OfraeKBT8GoU7iigG AXWkwNuTQxakEhy2c6poHWwCiHaRYUuuwZHyczcCRPTE+qqPAwPVZtxnPBaPVODKehJIqwPBq mt5XfBWtB9v0n4pTxh2iuYClR1cDKUgqigvIJ9Q8FdIDMhONfzTODo4clmzxRImXM98CsK4t9 h0TauNUL63t+64qmXYFate8IFZ+LEAORp+m0phKrxKeND5U3V3z7C3b53gVS1Zv48rOc3gwC2 aT2Hdr3GgycmBpMIT+/mozzC5XOoTjOFe66OxfG7B1LcIi8uk9k7sgso1RoG2KRDyvmWnvQsY Ob7xqJtwQld1AlTPYdhQc4zke/Q5zHj9rhjOt557IslfDGSCfoZEwaVYTnM7i2UJdBKEYI8ZO pwtNtkW3fTEFWdsjIlPOhL/mAOF1X/2CdkRNW5y5rexDuGlshdmd3ntiRSx2m6WMSvdwaIdek jUyoRxEa3USQjtlItwAP8wju2Rp/2n6Cmtvt9iKRv/wUXTRQiLL8HZMECTjBGeABhhR/5Qtnl be+lNGWsIka7jja/Fh3nkdlOdhRXWKbNChKH5eDqi1THPVAusB5cWvRTX5u8BKGePv4fbtMeN mn/fSyDGKk1bYBSosXslM0+Q740eRGkHwh4Uh0IXW63IDJl10TSLsf/fPy+cvEG7aXSBf1nit JgIb/f4UcmOZWw7RtpJp9tAHXS3l0K39iiXTmwVAO96wqc8wiv/BeRlxQig35w2GABPeBS9Pr ldpfeRyxcGfpZjPwin6ysuUz9UhIyfEKtS7EX9JAYGV7xZg6sEWDO+jqTl1yjWxEoZ6LuWbsc ITlE7f7QsTIDmhF+LP1Tf8BoCuqhrFFCrxTXEWGB8BLbxz+mDFC1CmG/bjCndJ+nXg4L5Kf+C GhTTqiXkzPDJBVbuls7+6vKjieXAzWI/UQ0yQUN3gZTs4e1xSebdAbsZjBo5xI6ZOiQzdsoSM dUNTWTswJsrQ13ccqQsodjIlFljjTulsZ0NXZ2QsjW17fyKUIhqLNjcAYLL0pI5g/Xe0H3TLt 0/B+RlUBtHBv2iChNynDP5Zdc7/un7hGR3twHUm9Ie4BnKndg+zaKGzs90tYzfxgZ7r5l68JI +33xtiLIoMh1t8DxtDGkJBQjwSxLpeAdvphCM5+R3UpDcd1L7EZHKUIKRBpc92K7HwyZ67E66 Wp3rjJyjAQEv5BNYyvlET8ytaGVfWZoaEUMQdRa1f+HShz2XvuLKhcVj+PelCe70BBmXlbBG1 n/5ul5iPPkLwaCzxnzZ0E2EKrDJds7AmguIMGsFQv+Gfu4PYys3BXdNAsYry2ijaPlkifZ+UY 0d9ENsvjE4ZAl1ThWMk0YdXlXrKxRZyUkLydExggwnxEQt4LxlvAKEHyTGKzv05NC3ZRXRI62 EEn3LL56Vn2A4iJtnWSkVDA+MSrWsbaY0YOWSc+w8DBomdIZzSSbvl+BWj3BniuCwJWQIMmTM QejT9SNa0krPC5Rc2jlolmZ8H4iNq5knR0yZInhJ4Lr2zTlgVOgQ4ONHjIMwmixliWUYEhRP2 SqQ9QJrfQfRtB4FSmUn+FGOkRZGi0j759sGoua0+XNwQaqz5TX3h/P27hmmnmxBvwa/IrNyAE Lo5blFK+DK77Ipwj4Bek9HQAhFsIeviyGsNy12C+ERNYhlyTBnAO3jVga
Hi nusenu
Thanks for digging into family_ids.
I confirm all active relays are listed correctly. The two relays
Ichotolot60/61 are shut down since April 4th and before that day never
received the Family-ID line. Maybe they bounce in some history stage in
the consensus.
> I noticed unexpected (missing) family_ids on relays using this CIISS
> url value:
>
> ...
> doedelkiste.de
> ...
Cheers,
Felix
Attachment:
pgp3wJymS356y.pgp
Description: Digitale Signatur von OpenPGP
_______________________________________________
tor-relays mailing list -- tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe send an email to tor-relays-leave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx