Re: [tor-dev] onionoo details document deterministic output

[nusenu <nusenu@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA512

Karsten Loesing:
>>> That timestamp is updated as last step of the hourly update
>>>>> process. The details documents that you're fetching may
>>>>> have been updated before.  That would also explain some
>>>>> differences.
>>> 
>>> Wouldn't it make sense to mention/use the timestamp of the 
>>> consensus that has been used to generate the output instead
>>> then?
> It *is* the timestamp of the consensus that has been used to
> generate the output.  But generating the documents that go into the
> output is not an atomic step.  It's an hourly cronjob that runs for
> 15--30 minutes and writes documents for all relays to disk, and
> only after that is done, the relays-published timestamp is updated
> on disk.  As I'm saying on one of the tickets, one way to change
> this would be to use a database and update all documents in a
> single transaction, but that's a major change to the current
> design.  Which doesn't mean we shouldn't do it, but it's not
> trivial, and maybe it's not the most pressing missing feature.

Would it be a quick and dirty fix to state the timestamp for every
record separately (to become "more atomic") or does that not fix
anything/is not possible? (I have no onionoo insides)
"fix" in terms of: a record with a given timestamp should not change
over time and multiple instances would provide the same record for a
given timestamp.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
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=ohOR
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
_______________________________________________
tor-dev mailing list
tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev