[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
Re: [tor-dev] HS v3 client authorization types
- To: tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Subject: Re: [tor-dev] HS v3 client authorization types
- From: Suphanat Chunhapanya <haxx.pop@xxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Fri, 13 Jul 2018 01:12:46 +0700
- Autocrypt: addr=haxx.pop@xxxxxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= xsFNBFaU83wBEADElEh5UmB+WXTKh5zL1IrUNebyA/pOdNOjY3phosuG2Xdth76PMhvyPXVu /Jf8GWDuDXhMrAKTGBloUuqbLpQsj6BY2YhV7Tn1wEiSqXCJMK8NdwrQhkUWKiX/ioxL4r4R cP9IUtDKkSstLhU7vk+7TUdQFIw4Y+qsNT+IgOvqpxlkIdieYNfExOvzXB9aWtVPfbpZ32S/ zTfZ8LBNXV9jWwFrMPZTFh8Dc9wzYQ/ZQUg8OckNSHNCYPiY0/x3x/FW4abBSJ376fxdQJNt x6f9dnOL8KEhv670Vt4S/NnXSo+jW0lzoDgE3PhpchQ3EaD/CgEYGEiIa8tnHERGpVRvPzwc jw1j9Cp/nFJL4eNVO+oOk9Iorh2LLID1z8vU+hgtoZZHQBSh7Gv+CmaV6DYCKwVxKxZkLKdX LauaweS32ZORb/eTaruXhSGFLgNFwjgurbSLw3FtUIcz8k7n5T2sx00C6kffaH5fZ8q5vj15 w7+l1KI0qCRS8XGm4bcfimgToRD858qbdi1vEcgygzewzDtDex7NfElpcg3krgNZHcBmfRI2 BVNRmlZWjsQNZOp5OhC/XuPGmkSlsZFgymYxHl8rraNlJeobMDjN3XYXLOMFMTqptOoYmw54 Mr+cOnFAu9R0qReEjBXXrpeECMX/2F1DYvus9x/zAV8Mku8BZQARAQABzTNTdXBoYW5hdCBD aHVuaGFwYW55YSAoaGF4eHBvcCkgPGhheHgucG9wQGdtYWlsLmNvbT7CwXgEEwECACIFAlaU 83wCGwMGCwkIBwMCBhUIAgkKCwQWAgMBAh4BAheAAAoJEGyq803SvUvTjF4QALoBadnJdTyJ /EcsqMCxysiQOqZNeppf3X/g/GHLLn52Y0XPud9JRXQRkBvLU2ax62N4vGtKT0WXhWKG5bgf pkH6rIRzKgJYtS4oYx6TjDKIQPK5Zup2XvqLtyxmssLCwKKXYqMurC/Vmzywq5nidOgdjD17 tO8PWGoSb4pm8XKm4cudhOaU+mF1B0tshjedBb3vSYnZ1Dmy3qOBx672ahU/L7ArIqOmH9+k 0FdeuQIjA4u0FU+p+JUZRVisqIkQP/gVc+5W1k/QqQm5gGFAtxD5mQ3eDvicd2aQ10NFRlTQ PTuFUfiouvNs5W6scaunv1IugSIbJY8e2fBSNkX+bf1vV4RXLC9CpZ+8YJoXB34LJRvHgkQ7 obL5A82mOG9ayMst3mDbJS8ASfZhKSliyXfo+W4XkPoOoSBAN7Sms/ZjMRXIAulbN0n5Pp8y xuCV1tL3ti7NxpvJEeTRBRmTawM3yGohX8rZiOdOFKuPvRCuUHUauASLacse8iTHwR1hYzuQ 1mv4hXo6RvOG0EUPUjEIHIIS3yFatXrTVpVr9DcgF8Dw+L2VaIqDg07GnunEyJ45YTMeJ5YG ZNngMhtDMf/diMIf9TOpUBohyeGLris3Opz3hkvn4zyeri2fCDzYkOi7dsgtqYox9HdYKj7a 80IBVWIOdT5nkJ1apAe4COwPzsFNBFaU83wBEAC3oeIL6xvJGo0VBSGrmXkbGBh3Q/wK0GLz YFZqGGAl1UuAPDGd5t8Z2QA+SENhVV/GxHS4H1D/srBzK2evm0yRcfEpye1EtK1HbcjsvIw1 IRklnuRs3+6bc6vS4eOREbFAFwheBn06RYWDOzuoTldEj25jasoPOyaNgmGJU4E2dHQac8ZS xLrVMrdXjV+SYfvwX0igf7MVRwhY6i5guIrAOsatFlwelBcOrh3SaA94G+vD8XpgYzWIm82s iB2wNcpn8HIXtbI5bupqKu8gSOEzpT/nRjOBQTRdMcKewy6h9dGI7DpHigzHSfIc6isV3h4S qgNT9oMic0TU8hzRetLw8g6qpUjtHb5hHOB0vkRHXT5o5iMp527ORrS3JASMBZwGCiZASOhl fI/F2l4b2YI9A0Y7pQVekUX1Arbj6fknFvfxeSKvpeowyLIgwMUEqPs8P9Ud6MGLw70JmR7y 8uEAM+jm4FZwQBrAxb633+vZndYDEEBpUV+pdCTN61m34MBdvbckdNnfiT2+Or+YSOub7J/Y M1SqqL2JXrCJrjWay90kWWtmJjKWZKPBeyoQ6/jlLrXebp0XJUf7rq2HsbMfzCf+j0QqXhlg TyJmcRC254OwUerDnkfSJ3dYiOewEPQNg+wFOxU+DI9Q90XlScmkRFHQld2hxj/e1UFsJaAN rwARAQABwsFfBBgBAgAJBQJWlPN8AhsMAAoJEGyq803SvUvTITIQAIRXbk8nGboVP+ByBmJg IASX2d0/VjTdhoRSsDZOjdMYH6EC0JAFvmt73glqIiDAbXNJdG7Xu5dmWz5MhEH1KuP2huOK JjbKHFrGZpTbgDM0kmBM2KBDf10y/fxor0JDJJXKfT5GDylryNtmecoTTLW9uum+RqM4STga +FkSgPYvh+I3TVH6fmzMvYsosATmWaYamtMqefPc7g4s6hBGhMiGWdtEaRTd6NObbGlVVlQs vTmc6Qabs+43h21nJHEquwtz8JjJqH6CMcV2aWTQdmt+Vp+C0wIXRZEQsWChftvWMmzxcc0R zy+ls1SpJKDUraGqDYxUPQvWj4Fyo3OSQ6WMuxZjHuAbh6S6G/1iUPQkYn+GabuCymL+t5Tt AeLGWHbdZZI8fo/EzGcTbGOKGOyTyLb4hPRudqe0WUHzPJmcC1fDuHrql96XFpMZaBzdDz64 YldU5CtBfPZVfwahw/RgFTt89Lvh9GfXmuLzmZcrmf2N/yn//lINCEeVLgpg0jgfXwBKf+/+ 66cVNuI7pWtHFk5apS/BbDac5EwYJ8yCPBR1Jhu55UjldlwP3vEulwM5zDnaiUn+O3/7qwFd 8QE1lSHQPh5STdS7tWaqita0A3xJAPH4TTmUT7C3H3KVN54+gj4IcQRU0ecrz0wv6MXTdDVD 1HgnSerf7ksyjU/c
- Delivered-to: archiver@xxxxxxxx
- Delivery-date: Thu, 12 Jul 2018 14:13:11 -0400
- Dkim-signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmail.com; s=20161025; h=subject:to:references:from:openpgp:autocrypt:message-id:date :user-agent:mime-version:in-reply-to; bh=C9/VJP5+CxQfAetUAgFpaCddjrNddMCIHWeMQjpAwSc=; b=EF6tjuF5WTH/ucFrfNUYAgGz9PUOQo7QqaxgLhY9kLnPnKoGFo6j2PnwEsOlf8YuPx SD8e8C60lR/GLuZUf/0jOAA7MsWJb9uiO+sBNtmgIo2ERSiIi2LqEYA63vR2zQ0oGjEA 3X2tHL7UsC7ihxz5fsn7qNGr0VWuTwnSne1sEqEj4YfbLqQzlH1ByALRykQclkJuhxYn /Sltv/iwufZVzC4j9WzN2Ioefnq+91hGX9GKFrS1cjlxddfdLyp2lcvMTK/EYxYYQ5WW h6VW5pYMAQLLNz5XHdyU4Kvm4COaqlcUZr3ulzIuBKTBTkXkONnHF1ls/vSPGHnubaPN N/mg==
- In-reply-to: <20180712174129.GB12821@raoul>
- List-archive: <http://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-dev/>
- List-help: <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=help>
- List-id: discussion regarding Tor development <tor-dev.lists.torproject.org>
- List-post: <mailto:tor-dev@lists.torproject.org>
- List-subscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev>, <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=subscribe>
- List-unsubscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/options/tor-dev>, <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=unsubscribe>
- Openpgp: preference=signencrypt
- References: <86y3h8l621.fsf@atlantis.meejah.ca> <53B585EE-002B-4BD9-9878-C3BF8117825B@gmail.com> <830d964a-d1c8-3719-0787-3d42405dc645@gmail.com> <87efiukpjr.fsf@riseup.net> <871seljjqc.fsf@riseup.net> <5cd3ddc8-c1c7-287c-cfea-7bbc825af55c@gmail.com> <20180514143817.GB24239@cs.uwaterloo.ca> <87bmdduf2a.fsf@riseup.net> <20180712154813.GA12821@raoul> <87r2k82wpl.fsf@riseup.net> <20180712174129.GB12821@raoul>
- Reply-to: tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Sender: "tor-dev" <tor-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:52.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/52.8.0
>
> Actually, we should have a simple format like "ed25519:<base64_key>" instead
> so then in 5 years, if we end up with 10 different authorization method, we
> can just pass "key:value" argument at will to the torrc option.
>
To be better, I prefer "ed25519:private:<base64_key>"
>>
>> Some more things to do:
>> - Rename "./client_authorized" to "./authorized_clients"?
>
> +1
+1
>> - What's the "auth-type"? I assume standard.
>
> We could use "descriptor" even though it won't stay much to a regular user, it
> will at least have a semantic for power users. Because even "standard" for
> regular user will probably mean nothing... ?
+1
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________
tor-dev mailing list
tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev