Re: [tor-dev] compass is unmaintained

[Nusenu <nusenu@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA512

Hi Karsten,

thanks for your reply.

>> -T --by-contact (#6675) (Maybe we should truncate contacts and 
>> remove the undefined)
> 
> I didn't look at the ticket or code, but truncating contacts
> sounds like it could confuse users more than help them.

You can judge by having a look the example that actually truncates
contactinfo here:

https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nusenu/misc-files/master/biggest_tor_relay_operators_by_MyFamily.txt

I can tell, it doesn't look as "nice" without truncation ;)

> Again, I didn't look at the code, but you might want to take into 
> account that there's no check whether the platform string says
> "Tor 1.2.3.4-something".  You should probably treat platform
> strings that don't stick to that schema as missing values.

Agreed. I also plan to have multiple group-by modes for version (and
other properties) using a radio button selections:

Group by version [] none [] major version [] exact match

> Heh, sounds like a hack that will confuse other contributors and
> the future you in 3 months from now.  It's probably worth rewriting
> this now, as long as you at least know why it's a quick hack.  It's
> going to take less time overall. :)

Agreed.

> I think it's awesome that you picked up Compass development *and*
> use it to find configuration problems of relay families and other 
> problems.  This is really great, thanks for doing this!

Thanks for the kind lines.

> Regarding the tickets and code changes, you should know that
> Compass doesn't have an active maintainer right now.  All I do is
> keep it running, but I can't work on enhancements nor review
> submitted patches.

So I guess it doesn't make sense to add/modify on any compass tickets
in trac(?).

> I think you should fork Compass, maybe give it a new name, run it
> on a small VM somewhere, and become the maintainer for that.

Ok, I'll investigate the feasibility of self-hosting a fork.

thanks,
Nusenu



-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
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=DAuk
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
_______________________________________________
tor-dev mailing list
tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev