[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
Re: [tor-dev] How does Tor plan to deal with HTTP/3 (HTTP over QUIC)
- To: tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Subject: Re: [tor-dev] How does Tor plan to deal with HTTP/3 (HTTP over QUIC)
- From: Iain Learmonth <irl@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Sat, 17 Nov 2018 16:40:20 +0000
- Autocrypt: addr=irl@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= xsFNBFZp8zEBEACxOYriD+tEuc3Wpnbh+GGnyiaLEMABBrfn6JlDQphbBq/YTz9M9OPkttjx hLL/yrxlM1nD69XbGKQ9gIL3LEgOz9+OdivPbN+Q5iNMqk/WCQUqd3bCFbbsn1yvoTumFy9S 9kYX45Db3jRJoN/Nye6Stf7KKPxHxot14iY+PUR/5Gx5KbeWVKfDtQejGnhxQD73KjrX4wds BAaxnQ7KbjQyUf+IxE+8qSDcyTP+pPqxspVzx+eFqsW5+kK1eJMHxJmY/KsAs6IsGf5lvyDJ JECc2iE0mFS6vc14lGcD7BAYMPRnvlK3OcDlbdJS3ZU0LQu3/AplM7cNcesq2Btm06OUTsbj 10ZiyLi7Q0WZRuUbn7t3jOQVyOlNfjUpJhKPMMobBL2R0KzcptJbUrKc08wZD/TPaXuHKWAE JuA6kFMXtHhV8Qhxz5/d2KUA8ex+zpVd2xSR6q4llcYu1w8zHZtLN+YKSmjjKs+AjiTrCMYs OYxt4cwxuaIIhBNvCC9WqZOxHX7YHmpVcSV6K9Wwhk9mVIU3Ii0G2HWs6OQ0vIueCDGMEdVk ig/a7cVlfXNz7WuaXuhOJmHz6d6Yk4dFn5mLbEY9cZhBxf5hjCwtp9b6v+ueuptfcnOd+38G 9KH6NyHKZyS4jcd3E6Dp0+9Isbl/EohjPCujevoW3/DlT08OKQARAQABzSBJYWluIFIuIExl YXJtb250aCA8aXJsQGZzZmUub3JnPsLBlwQTAQoAQQIbAwULCQgHAwUVCgkICwUWAgMBAAIe AQIXgAIZARYhBKj3ulBB4TMznLoWlnbVgJP1QKvNBQJbdd1aBQkF+TgpAAoJEHbVgJP1QKvN EkwP/2YqUwPxN81uEE62hu37Vsn4USvpuOicFbh4i4reNRDBRtHk/vGvez9lJHC456LWb2pr 0Gg3nSBgeZrjkqdREgnxf3DG6sW5xpEIMXB65MzJ03EVvFrURnbygR6Ft+FOrjDjN1RnpyxP 6zbH15XJpGAI0eEt0oVRk+PUNxXJ6AklG/xqIPj/S9XIHGUAGbGEFdmeG5xphfjTG+fwsEqX cPD5f9QnahtGMxSx6GQKzrx5Mm0Q078ViYW8jhdhPQMQPdYOjZeZ8/UP/SYgv7o+WrTi+Y2v A8wZnmzbAdfL7oqlAfEMcuBijF16NX4i96c23x/W1r6kiazfMd98o9Hvgg9UEOe4VIZeIZ1l KcYO0Q24X69XpdtXERKdwER1hlfkbk4Hw5FQpXA98hE43LMqorSjK4tLa8ndNoMvcNPLsxpi TLKF6pozhqM/FrJ58oKV3sgfSouJ7auzCZOBSHPZ+bkJPtGo4NmOyU7CgFeDowpyayuMwyb+ tHjFafn1sgYC04E79j97nMXBdMoKOoP8Y+txHNzXtXEkgB6jo6PDjKNNy2WmIhA7sANI5Vn0 hiFb7UNKot227pEWm8uDUIcLlNaJoQOOgSGggvHPtNHnSnptEjL2l65X/epXbMk29/xMIspp /tzsYPtbk+RfWQGaC0gm1890ziTuWo3ZY79m9335zsFNBFprf6sBEADOANf22so7uoGcvok2 TM/T8BHI5+TqHEc4hVe+JGGJ1ZnWlgtGmpOs0fOQj3WAgGI0ZmTqMuozKF/K9ljbjaMXsLD+ JIBTD4rINy60VX2zHhmWhNaOcJvq+wbuHx0tMbhqsTStGnSkvRhH61ncMqVqlTTTLVQQSxKl 9D2l7ZGwEPLHRFlydTOOix+F+Y1ehxYLVaPkaycs8wvgjYsDLo3T8TmuOL+rcEfvxJ6lT2V5 I51xqievqoBazAfXvA8FW/0G+Z9LUJmViOVluWg3xjP8okKYgOkOeX00vMBCVaiEA08oaxY0 ebS7uBEgppjWSwn+WAhB+6spd67d4W+DmAnM262lxFMhVYhXpfeV9zygULQOofdE6xtFkaxr /y8xQ4Bf7zX8ko6X9aFQFB/vc+zUtjzjg4VaQvWrThjaHlbEKR55MDxJu2T9S7g5bR4zxZNv 36gwlIdmx33a1AeR1nGcWa/7OtoS53+lUwyFVWLOnucqKh71Y38AAMd5L9Fsb+ArQem71knE UTC+HvBGkPb2Y2PzGnnzhZyC8zgE8AjVD0wB+RMDNI3+fIW6biKAHDqrS6ZCVkzJ1R9nOjXM HRYZ5qlG+rCOeu6Jp4yNwp46z4PqiiLJ9NtmdNttLCEn5PDVF3g9g811JcadvFVH1ZELoDGW Mg3Q+QOHQBFYj7cj2QARAQABwsF8BBgBCgAmAhsMFiEEqPe6UEHhMzOcuhaWdtWAk/VAq80F Alt13YwFCQH3q+EACgkQdtWAk/VAq83bIQ//UEUryjH/AEwY7R2j6KDjQ0QmGsxa+zXN20rG 8YgHkeweBDpIcgT96miYb818kfQn+lAew8mdlOfTpld0YgsVopWxQFumEDUthMD4oYUX5a1m n0YhjtbqlDZwx5jolEnNGPOf0d0hDbOAzie6/rPbdS/yLsBgAp+THfKmxA/PEtQcmtirtUWP XTLNLMGrZFI0pJqsFe9GwLhWejFS+KqS9uWRsHLct1gb61LSbro3sOIUZb/JQf3Vv4mnCViK Ds8qIM5SaIdLY9c8jlYBDJdr5CZw+SDmQN2rWCFWYU07ngs7ETD6Lj47NO+yALntH6gC0Olj Qylt0xyiKdnmwakX7h0PpLbGbyAILZ4a2f8hC/rJhfraLpGVl+E7OdIEbHdySt2HYefMw8A0 8bXvC6/k7t2FXqfQ13uWDOSHjvJodFS5fkfLl0VX/r26B6dGWi3vaMG7skF7hn2VDt9WcRD6 leOUH8AaIFOZRLLoxRlc4A39pFjqvQNt+tzxPZR5L5lSEWlLs/WsePQhn68eIwP3PMN27y32 Jl7DJIMX0eCaR7+wAyBZaeK0+Zw9Oja8tNshWEhkzZhsVIa1iKcekmxPMtpC9lQiOqwurRzu C0elrs4WDU29Lnd1lgeyl7+5jxHXyFMVjnssnHg5ltw/J4G7aYAffxWaFd3wBssRsxkTR4c=
- Delivered-to: archiver@xxxxxxxx
- Delivery-date: Sat, 17 Nov 2018 11:40:38 -0500
- Dkim-signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d= messagingengine.com; h=content-type:date:from:in-reply-to :message-id:mime-version:references:subject:to:x-me-proxy :x-me-proxy:x-me-sender:x-me-sender:x-sasl-enc; s=fm1; bh=c9j4fJ v5FHLTdNXl7N6aQGO2nn2GmO50gxXRs6HRMXw=; b=vynRr/ou+hGINeKRoFLe8f SzaM8uLejRPn13Fit+Zxe5J1tJJ6/wPaUY4PF2q6ghzwTYq5uzW4CdmbjbS+npcV uEFQCu2z1vRuTofcE7Y2683gEjVXVb1lRBJLvEIR2URMWc8s6O16HvNc+GqPPgpd QyoH5KMJ1V0+r5Dtp1nn1F9zReUM6Mtl6BtmSF1baRPNhTYOplSn5yZI/q4lqEkK AslLZA62l0Nupc4xKhT0979QozX7ZO656vQw8MIJ0ITbVZJBuMe1t4PRVUnqY6m5 S3Rfx3nE1d1KkOvPOSfBD5Hl0wNB5doqJP3MD2EC7F/KTivw4Avf+s1mJ0MoVIyQ ==
- In-reply-to: <6944a54f51ee8ff6f4095e50bae1ae65@neelc.org>
- List-archive: <http://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-dev/>
- List-help: <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=help>
- List-id: discussion regarding Tor development <tor-dev.lists.torproject.org>
- List-post: <mailto:tor-dev@lists.torproject.org>
- List-subscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev>, <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=subscribe>
- List-unsubscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/options/tor-dev>, <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=unsubscribe>
- Openpgp: preference=signencrypt
- Organization: Tor Project
- References: <6944a54f51ee8ff6f4095e50bae1ae65@neelc.org>
- Reply-to: tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Sender: "tor-dev" <tor-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:52.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/52.9.1
Hi,
On 15/11/18 02:02, neel@xxxxxxxxx wrote:
> How would Tor deal with HTTP/3 (a.k.a. HTTP over QUIC), considering that Tor is a TCP anonymizer, and HTTP over QUIC (and QUIC itseld) uses UDP? Would we need Tor to support UDP? Just QUIC?
One reason we don't support UDP in Tor because it is connection-less,
and the connection concept in TCP means that the server at the other end
needs to accept the connection before we start sending larger amounts of
data to it.
Saying this, QUIC is not UDP. It may use UDP for the sake of middlebox
traversal but is in fact a connection-oriented transport protocol. (If
you ignore the unreliable datagrams draft currently in the IETF QUIC WG).
This recent presentation at the IETF looks at some of the ways that QUIC
and HTTP/QUIC can be tunneled from the perspective of the client
interface and the exit relay:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/102/materials/slides-102-httpbis-hint-and-helium-for-udp-and-ip-tunnelling-00
To really get benefits from things like streams, it could be necessary
to map some of the QUIC internals into the Tor protocol.
Note that SOCKS 5 actually does already support UDP, we just don't
implement this part of the protocol for clients.
I'm not a Network Team person so I don't know if this is currently
something being considered, but given that the IETF hasn't actually
standardized QUIC yet this is probably not going to be needed urgently.
Thanks,
Iain.
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________
tor-dev mailing list
tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev