[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
Re: [tor-relays] Status of Bug #7349 - Obfsbridges should be able to "disable" their ORPort?
- To: tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Subject: Re: [tor-relays] Status of Bug #7349 - Obfsbridges should be able to "disable" their ORPort?
- From: meskio <meskio@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Fri, 16 Dec 2022 17:07:04 +0100
- Autocrypt: : addr=meskio@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata=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 00egydI7qQoKnpe6AUX+kYkOvQeQGAm5msI13shZmadKHAP6uKbCqwLW4ZmSJ0pGQeNgQxEsZYOoDL12NYZakhUyhQiruj7Wffbn7FCCa7L7diqRjzCkZdRxiaR6jOG5VRdfkvgXXoMh1Mzxh8m0KBIBEsryhUberxV4KlBnvE2ynAzl+jrTJEqif7cFGsO5u71nrHCsInFsmK4qh9WJyaqFpCGvwKWIPpRbqncMHJMVdE9ExPvvjlB3YM+YRX8U3EJpzE8oE15X2SAEXgYQECehz2S1K7JCC9VHwB2Ct0yJM3KMSzakNjBvJ+x9AcxmOv/z0KERRpLThAB5Fnmht9bD5w47t7rxkMKZK2hMgkOpzdz8WnKvZFZtr0/+jkme0CcixcC0qCYa+XPuTLKomyGuuI8dvcZOWsoMcs6LimMEVdvAXOYiNp2LecL3TokrQngc3WNBiCAV8E+zVIrBMRWKl2oXvW9xqPD7fVpYD+ObWpy9HfUcaQOojeeOusVukEkKikl20TJIOwwP+PvJUmpezHURVkPm+pSUOftoJffRy7D8hcJo+a4hasGGkWHQMmbvwqcyjGhJOyPxNoQf7adiyIfNmAt1YHGABY2LShMs0i7I7gos7BTQRYW41XARAAoKxj7hf5PTZTA9GuZo2br3xqJGptysjJ6KbfMR1qanH5atKKBSEgKUCpBb4ojZYofGZpqwf4eBKqoarP8hx39y6kcnHZoHPPPuibjs4/JjpTqIz3pS7dmvK8nfGY8EE7FUNkLxJHenJ14gXB2QHdV22vkZhIUGT4l20IP8sg5pHVwiRaVT9Fc80YkDa+rpNWl35hquuLXPnCfcFYdjcF4srOlpLfajes4zHfHZAQ5VJbEY0e7AL/R+XF+7E0aZxiJvZCyHWZvyPSui/x5dOho3+1KrP9tj2679MUK8PKYsyH76Z9/urIzzXPXqnZvR99q/HGFAFMfJ7CZG8/r1siAU3G4ZpvNfcJFJT 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 /9DkN/YZlk0AYh6xn+oSOqRTPlwhNAVeq1nsw/GRoT/jAuocj8JqgQGQNjbeZxS+x1jMbVDSiwmluNWJdljoY95ufRhBBykVWLjoNVDJa8+ac0GGU7HKkBHjXzTYn4XLf1PNy2i9in2NAUsP69knHTA/rLASiUkfKHrPvK9sZB4EjV0C7EiGkYXD+DbGTH91SVUF/p2JwaM7UGAou/EZzVt6XgQw+Af9ru/coJXpKvnYaBWgLCkRF45AdbspwottaxPuP6JagLG6Erp9c3V6u6ETv2bI7OVnSy8d7Eb/K8t782/V0TIuO5ad4Q+/6myg== '
- Delivered-to: archiver@xxxxxxxx
- Delivery-date: Fri, 16 Dec 2022 11:07:40 -0500
- Dkim-signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=simple/simple; d=torproject.org; s=2022-eugeni; t=1671206854; bh=JKBBjeTm7LDi9M7ZhWYBOL89jaRsKQMlL9/Kd6YKQDU=; h=In-Reply-To:References:To:From:Date:Subject:List-Id: List-Unsubscribe:List-Archive:List-Post:List-Help:List-Subscribe: Reply-To:From; b=bpWLwbOiLzP8Oc2JjFcFkPi+Cr4inVJY3AvUGd2SaZTHT5EpWpZQ3aRk+0wipvbzD u14Kh2q1CE6dgkax3K5mWKqf1yQXgFSZqKVJlIxA3d2cxLONRrObYZwZ7yUTH1l6sn LMKjfUUJz+Rn4bVUNBqwYtyWxda8uVyo0D1HHsAhifisJ6BVQSV/HwrQvbHdsFWDqN npTEesL9j5SdTR0YZ3mMcXp1rEcjo0S1KoXnhl7YhBoMNZCiZJZA2pB2v1E0WJfTE7 9+n1+256jtTOQD0meJT0UEC/fdVZqo3BXlPvAlkWD7uQ4y4+Fve0KYOfpOuOHrVejp /fNnPpbrMNAlg==
- In-reply-to: <1357923210.3754648.1670642448513@mail.yahoo.com>
- List-archive: <http://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-relays/>
- List-help: <mailto:tor-relays-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=help>
- List-id: "support and questions about running Tor relays \(exit, non-exit, bridge\)" <tor-relays.lists.torproject.org>
- List-post: <mailto:tor-relays@lists.torproject.org>
- List-subscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays>, <mailto:tor-relays-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=subscribe>
- List-unsubscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/options/tor-relays>, <mailto:tor-relays-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=unsubscribe>
- References: <1357923210.3754648.1670642448513.ref@mail.yahoo.com> <1357923210.3754648.1670642448513@mail.yahoo.com>
- Reply-to: tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Sender: "tor-relays" <tor-relays-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Quoting Gary C. New via tor-relays (2022-12-10 04:20:48)
> What is the status of Bug #7349 - Obfsbridges should be able to "disable"
> their ORPort?
> https://bugs.torproject.org/tpo/core/tor/7349
> I recently setup a loadbalanced OBFS4 bridge and would prefer not to expose the ORPort to the World.
> I've noticed that some of the tasks to make this possible have been implemented, but it isn't clear whether everything needed is in place as I receive a bridge/relay down status on metrics.torproject.org when the ORPort isn't exposed to the World.
We do still need the ORPort reachable. The bridge authority does use that port
to check if the bridge is running (marking the 'running' flag to it). We are
still using that flag to decide what bridges are distributed, we'll like to
revisit that in the future. But for now, please expose the ORPort to the world.
--
meskio | https://meskio.net/
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
My contact info: https://meskio.net/crypto.txt
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Nos vamos a Croatan.
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: signature
_______________________________________________
tor-relays mailing list
tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays