[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
Re: [tor-relays] Question regarding ethical torrent blocking
- To: tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Subject: Re: [tor-relays] Question regarding ethical torrent blocking
- From: Matt Traudt <pastly@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Sun, 15 Jul 2018 13:41:39 -0400
- Autocrypt: addr=pastly@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= xsFNBFYSsCYBEACtCAyNCpmHR4A3L4AWF9UbhZDu76D3LxZHSuPkCWOI++7Lm1SZ0QTuDsd0 ncp6qmzx56wbL9rmRwgNHFCPxlEv1zHmGDoGS/h1CVLsOXpEKqmyyCysYygp+Fc6N5aXIlCm lBj4xEnjz3aSdA0T6RAUOJRLDvmH0hs3guPsJ5Ic12+WekkgqXrNPKoI8PEa1MVFB8RT/49+ SZp28zTk951LXFy2Gte+r/FmNIoKCgMvyBJ5y+vRDIERZhA3S/U9w66zflpBhSRco9VG2fZX Pe2Y5OiC9sLJoHHce7QLIsMbepzGDWIDyIkveMDHPByJL2i3+ajQvv4mRl/WFOUXQJ+HgtA4 o7ul8KSPghmkXJBPTc1nb4U6yPE+cJgx1PhAkc6pcHOo3bf9tnozr4IdkiG/1bvInLqTqm30 nJOloNLVLt6WhhWEt9tUJrcXMSZwhuABgxzz+HvvE19XFzvCCm9xU0dh2kgQ2PAnmK8QsH4b h2M9bkH+WEgMZdh4tNcJdj4UtH/OL8R22+E198lq4C9SMj5DEocllshIVpXRJb2wz91rgP+t dYfjGV/nlnQDKCK1S/+rjSnu4Li3dzTrcNS2rewlVuyUeM5gCnmp6vVZh9xiF/HvYPhKr68J heuo7mq9EJeeuMOcedf5d/zC5fNcdmalYbM8Ow5BT0ZLveIzuQARAQABzR1NYXR0IFRyYXVk dCA8c2lybWF0dEBrc3UuZWR1PsLBmAQTAQIAQgIbAwUJCWYBgAYLCQgHAwIGFQgCCQoLBBYC AwECHgECF4AWIQS34QX8Tm2Td/icukyDvKlSlPu7CgUCWjbKkgIZAQAKCRCDvKlSlPu7Ctc3 D/4mtWXBTipGassxKMhDsG/agzppIpXP5HB7GCLCBZgncIboseB6ckUrNOw/a7RTlQEwaY1G 1NDoV9+l00nozo6X11OrO2uvhJmisa5oHnpZv5BE/pTq96Fgu2Inr+y8RUXG6B+67tgxipcj S9YpDvBHGeE3xsnhirmaJykQSzrwb9VVsdpiF5pNVbBwzqSKFgCaD6j52wZvGiIFHjKssKTq SXvO+AE9R1pyL1okRJxG/LE5y2vfnn2rnoq225Uwb+inCNUPQtO5YW0+hjE8p3/3aR9xftdU 6OnflKmESu0oJRAy1jzsupZyIzvMfb6a6IxQyBlpL+//NyNtYZ2ELL9ViRMsK2ijUIYIY8ap BFJrg6ybgdSIxMrdj6wuCke/gFA2m2ksWfXOmypoZ+4Mi7aHABylWYUVI2yFUe1xUaxeoZpw MGn0VIemmg9fHqhC4TJL56MKgo31Jj2njQ/tuWcg/lTdk3+CAlPMuRDvuDPKyUA7hu7FEWxR sTBvzCIxY0Qit5Jez9G8Ea87Ekt6lZUMG8paN25qbkEBzKRifjzuNE0kHwWU9t6dYymseMF5 fjVFiA9BGiIQlvEmFvx1q1Jp12e5dumuCBWDCjjOJmo3vJGxihPSIpXamVxdx22sxMMnOOdD A8qU1QTm78hkDW1OEhS3OaDUwcwWtLIs4r8epM7BTQRWErAmARAAqku3mxb1nGqyHNqQGwRQ HIHWb0ubhwleHqtt2nQkG4NcQTDVw1c6u1lNo3OwrtB8DyfTqFFHD7n/xIMIhfmtAPyK2Qts 41cs73S2e/jKj43vH39vx48WbOxuUrNWriEhajjuu8D4eI0XMvzPdVPiQYBWR9kgLAzYHBsS tk+pxVohF3fGPp7RFCYV7DK2pKvqKYnbWDEZCuT8VtyJ0BT/cudkl0e+0uY85qWXNKVYPnuB LpXrc9ushkzNqYsHeI22NKzN+KHhzTfMNjBKNJK2JWuzYSt3ZgCqB7u5ElMpqf/ynSYukXTu z9JngUuB0vrGqUFCc/qUH/uMrhyRT8gFRQ125CYPkAmYRDbquM5iT4vIP+FfxPStTay/HTcY VsEON2Xkt907OhQBQD4XXXt0FUmufbv7SheLKjAJYrc8qUaG1SZo56JPO4zFcYrJX4mS9y22 VE1do8TMBF3UczbMilKAH1TnNnjxXxcLL+5TSvRA9L3TqErTs6URkYG9ABTiQIwC0IVEt9zk UEniL2M3tSiH/cF91RlyCKuJl2O5NNl79rRaXn7tN33dY3Am1p8+zfh7zO8YlePoQk2mgGUO /LeD7jD69Eau4wlj/H7eAgyPsUGmqn05nW8Xs8faFacE+gGwIDgJGomN1GOs11LTe73s/khs YlWH/OF1LDFlDwEAEQEAAcLBZQQYAQIADwUCVhKwJgIbDAUJCWYBgAAKCRCDvKlSlPu7CvPP D/9tRwoRPKtS03w+koDIiZoky08y+j4OQ/bqz0WN6p9gxKOKAfIyH8Jb521r74gtnwAvf9XY CCzjbzUAkYSO9rB3X3wS4xPmldVrvx0eihJNuoDdCekKicMc63MnKwSvwV20pb/1aFDWZZHZ XFFzU+4OXUyAvm3EUY2+UY7/y/MkYdMoMjDo048Ab2U+AFFC/P1qOiHXKpEeMR6bIme51+Ac 7cBDJiuSpnrXy+nZZvKi6HaxAK6HkTeAlfiY6HheQ95zjP+zAgJbtCi49WPdkQIQi+cnG6r8 gV29MojNAN5FmaLoTM8iQ2UyFd61Hq3nefrfCli/ijWjtoKAtDf8xxcfxgOQDiO+G1nSiEtG Lqt8+epRFyV+b7hxFpfsg3Od85XNpR2vg0CymnJ4W4+JZ/RkSr1hP25+TOI/rZC9EsuUHPRk iVw3Cf3+/2BmncboRZieMcprR5HxPb+FO3W6a+rFZKWuoxNSasGGyrhD7Bg7HIRZnbAM+db5 QLGcnQx6zzKFjsL4pjdjhY6IuYKdun9GvuvZ0dRHs5AhkdXpeNY8n/tt9JvNltjZ20ARlfSN /35prOrFGjc5qrtKQCjcCgFdhrvl9mDdJI9yFtWZYoXUa+EARU4d2MQv2GngPH9aeSh/yMRg eZo5Mqs64Hs/GUYInXGnbkyMKjw1sOAV9CFxHA==
- Delivered-to: archiver@xxxxxxxx
- Delivery-date: Sun, 15 Jul 2018 13:41:58 -0400
- In-reply-to: <CACiAZpjD1Srj=zz0xOWsizdZ3+8xS+Bx7Q=ngpOm8tAhBRR_KQ@mail.gmail.com>
- List-archive: <http://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-relays/>
- List-help: <mailto:tor-relays-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=help>
- List-id: "support and questions about running Tor relays \(exit, non-exit, bridge\)" <tor-relays.lists.torproject.org>
- List-post: <mailto:tor-relays@lists.torproject.org>
- List-subscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays>, <mailto:tor-relays-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=subscribe>
- List-unsubscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/options/tor-relays>, <mailto:tor-relays-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=unsubscribe>
- Openpgp: preference=signencrypt
- References: <CACiAZphcxEYpw4OkW1DQ5u+To2C5cik5KxKzcE4=tC5b_54HzQ@mail.gmail.com> <ef00172f-8d86-7b48-e158-f2b04e08a6c5@torproject.org> <CACiAZpjD1Srj=zz0xOWsizdZ3+8xS+Bx7Q=ngpOm8tAhBRR_KQ@mail.gmail.com>
- Reply-to: tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Sender: "tor-relays" <tor-relays-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
On 07/15/2018 01:21 PM, Conrad Rockenhaus wrote:
> Hello,
>
>> Tor is designed in such a way that you can separately decide whether or
>> not you want to contribute to the network, and also whether or not you
>> are willing to deal with abuse notices. This is configured via exit
>> policies.
>
> I never said that, I asked if people felt it was ethical to still
> consider themselves contributing to "Full Free Speech" by running the
> default exit policy then to start deviating from the default exit
> policy and blocking items such as access to bittorrent. Basically, my
> concern is I see a legitimate use of bittorrent, which is why I never
> blocked it on my exits. Now I'm being forced to. I'm asking if other
> people view themselves as "Full Free Speech" still or are we starting
> to arbitrate free speech?
>
Even when using the default exit policy you are blocking some ports. For
example, SMTP on port 25.
There are legitimate reasons to use port 25. You're already blocking
those users that want to use 25. If you choose to define supporting Full
Free Speech as allowing all traffic, you already stopped supporting FFS.
Personally I'd rather support 99.9% of Tor users (made up percentage)
forever than support 100% of Tor users for a limited time.
I don't run the default exit policy on all my relays and I don't see
anything wrong with my decision.
Hope that helps. Thanks for running a relay(s).
Matt
PS: for reference, the default exit policy is as follows according to
the Tor manual. https://www.torproject.org/docs/tor-manual.html.en
reject *:25
reject *:119
reject *:135-139
reject *:445
reject *:563
reject *:1214
reject *:4661-4666
reject *:6346-6429
reject *:6699
reject *:6881-6999
accept *:*
_______________________________________________
tor-relays mailing list
tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays