[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
Re: [tor-relays] >23% Tor exit relay capacity found to be malicious - call for support for proposal to limit large scale attacks
- To: tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Subject: Re: [tor-relays] >23% Tor exit relay capacity found to be malicious - call for support for proposal to limit large scale attacks
- From: Toralf Förster <toralf.foerster@xxxxxx>
- Date: Wed, 8 Jul 2020 17:22:44 +0200
- Autocrypt: addr=toralf.foerster@xxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= mQSuBFKhflgRDADrUSTZ9WJm+pL686syYr9SrBnaqul7zWKSq8XypEq0RNds0nEtAyON96pD xuMj26LNztqsEA0sB69PQq4yHno0TxA5+Fe3ulrDxAGBftSPgo/rpVKB//d6B8J8heyBlbiV y1TpPrOh3BEWzfqw6MyRwzxnRq6LlrRpiCRa/qAuxJXZ9HTEOVcLbeA6EdvLEBscz5Ksj/eH 9Q3U97jr26sjFROwJ8YVUg+JKzmjQfvGmVOChmZqDb8WZJIE7yV6lJaPmuO4zXJxPyB3Ip6J iXor1vyBZYeTcf1eiMYAkaW0xRMYslZzV5RpUnwDIIXs4vLKt9W9/vzFS0Aevp8ysLEXnjjm e88iTtN5/wgVoRugh7hG8maZCdy3ArZ8SfjxSDNVsSdeisYQ3Tb4jRMlOr6KGwTUgQT2exyC 2noq9DcBX0itNlX2MaLL/pPdrgUVz+Oui3Q4mCNC8EprhPz+Pj2Jw0TwAauZqlb1IdxfG5fD tFmV8VvG3BAE2zeGTS8sJycBAI+waDPhP5OptN8EyPGoLc6IwzHb9FsDa5qpwLpRiRcjDADb oBfXDt8vmH6Dg0oUYpqYyiXx7PmS/1z2WNLV+/+onAWV28tmFXd1YzYXlt1+koX57k7kMQbR rggc0C5erweKl/frKgCbBcLw+XjMuYk3KbMqb/wgwy74+V4Fd59k0ig7TrAfKnUFu1w40LHh RoSFKeNso114zi/oia8W3Rtr3H2u177A8PC/A5N34PHjGzQz11dUiJfFvQAi0tXO+WZkNj3V DSSSVYZdffGMGC+pu4YOypz6a+GjfFff3ruV5XGzF3ws2CiPPXWN7CDQK54ZEh2dDsAeskRu kE/olD2g5vVLtS8fpsM2rYkuDjiLHA6nBYtNECWwDB0ChH+Q6cIJNfp9puDxhWpUEpcLxKc+ pD4meP1EPd6qNvIdbMLTlPZ190uhXYwWtO8JTCw5pLkpvRjYODCyCgk0ZQyTgrTUKOi/qaBn ChV2x7Wk5Uv5Kf9DRf1v5YzonO8GHbFfVInJmA7vxCN3a4D9pXPCSFjNEb6fjVhqqNxN8XZE GfpKPBMMAIKNhcutwFR7VMqtB0YnhwWBij0Nrmv22+yXzPGsGoQ0QzJ/FfXBZmgorA3V0liL 9MGbGMwOovMAc56Zh9WfqRM8gvsItEZK8e0voSiG3P/9OitaSe8bCZ3ZjDSWm5zEC2ZOc1Pw VO1pOVgrTGY0bZ+xaI9Dx1WdiSCm1eL4BPcJbaXSNjRza2KFokKj+zpSmG5E36Kdn13VJxhV lWySzJ0x6s4eGVu8hDT4pkNpQUJXjzjSSGBy5SIwX+fNkDiXEuLLj2wlV23oUfCrMdTIyXu9 Adn9ECc+vciNsCuSrYH4ut7gX0Rfh89OJj7bKLmSeJq2UdlU3IYmaBHqTmeXg84tYB2gLXaI MrEpMzvGxuxPpATNLhgBKf70QeJr8Wo8E0lMufX7ShKbBZyeMdFY5L3HBt0I7e4ev+FoLMzc FA9RuY9q5miLe9GJb7dyb/R89JNWNSG4tUCYcwxSkijaprBOsoMKK4Yfsz9RuNfYCn1HNykW 1aC2Luct4lcLPtg44LQ1VG9yYWxmIEbDtnJzdGVyIChteSAybmQga2V5KSA8dG9yYWxmLmZv ZXJzdGVyQGdteC5kZT6IgQQTEQgAKQUCUqF+WAIbIwUJEswDAAcLCQgHAwIBBhUIAgkKCwQW AgMBAh4BAheAAAoJEMTqzd4AdulO06EBAIBfWzAIRkMwpCEhY4ZHexa4Ge8C/ql/sBiW8+na FxbZAP9z0OgF2zcorcfdttWw0aolhmUBlOf14FWXYDEkHKrmlbkEDQRSoX5YEBAA2tKn0qf0 kVKRPxCs8AledIwNuVcTplm9MQ+KOZBomOQz8PKru8WXXstQ6RA43zg2Q2WU//ly1sG9WwJN Mzbo5d+8+KqgBD0zKKM+sfTLi1zIH3QmeplEHzyv2gN6fe8CuIhCsVhTNTFgaBTXm/aEUvTI zn7DIhatKmtGYjSmIwRKP8KuUDF/vQ1UQUvKVJX3/Z0bBXFY8VF/2qYXZRdj+Hm8mhRtmopQ oTHTWd+vaT7WqTnvHqKzTPIm++GxjoWjchhtFTfYZDkkF1ETc18YXXT1aipZCI3BvZRCP4HT hiAC5Y0aITZKfHtrjKt13sg7KTw4rpCcNgo67IQmyPBOsu2+ddEUqWDrem/zcFYQ360dzBfY tJx2oSspVZ4g8pFrvCccdShx3DyVshZWkwHAsxMUES+Bs2LLgFTcGUlD4Z5O9AyjRR8FTndU 7Xo9M+sz3jsiccDYYlieSDD0Yx8dJZzAadFRTjBFHBDA7af1IWnGA6JY07ohnH8XzmRNbVFB /8E6AmFA6VpYG/SY02LAD9YGFdFRlEnN7xIDsLFbbiyvMY4LbjB91yBdPtaNQokYqA+uVFwO inHaLQVOfDo1JDwkXtqaSSUuWJyLkwTzqABNpBszw9jcpdXwwxXJMY6xLT0jiP8TxNU8EbjM TeC+CYMHaJoMmArKJ8VmTerMZFsAAwUQAJ3vhEE+6s+wreHpqh/NQPWL6Ua5losTCVxY1snB 3WXF6y9Qo6lWducVhDGNHjRRRJZihVHdqsXt8ZHz8zPjnusB+Fp6xxO7JUy3SvBWHbbBuheS fxxEPaRnWXEygI2JchSOKSJ8Dfeeu4H1bySt15uo4ryAJnZ+jPntwhncClxUJUYVMCOdk1PG j0FvWeCZFcQ+bapiZYNtju6BEs9OI73g9tiiioV1VTyuupnE+C/KTCpeI5wAN9s6PJ9LfYcl jOiTn+037ybQZROv8hVJ53jZafyvYJ/qTUnfDhkClv3SqskDtJGJ84BPKK5h3/U3y06lWFoi wrE22plnEUQDIjKWBHutns0qTF+HtdGpGo79xAlIqMXPafJhLS4zukeCvFDPW2PV3A3RKU7C /CbgGj/KsF6iPQXYkfF/0oexgP9W9BDSMdAFhbc92YbwNIctBp2Trh2ZEkioeU0ZMJqmqD3Z De/N0S87CA34PYmVuTRt/HFSx9KA4bAWJjTuq2jwJNcQVXTrbUhy2Et9rhzBylFrA3nuZHWf 4Li6vBHn0bLP/8hos1GANVRMHudJ1x3hN68TXU8gxpjBkZkAUJwt0XThgIA3O8CiwEGs6aam oxxAJrASyu6cKI8VznuhPOQ9XdeAAXBg5F0hH/pQ532qH7zL9Z4lZ+DKHIp4AREawXNxiGYE GBEIAA8FAlKhflgCGwwFCRLMAwAACgkQxOrN3gB26U7PNwEAg6z1II04TFWGV6m8lR/0ZsDO 15C9fRjklQTFemdCJugA+PvUpIsYgyqSb3OVodAWn4rnnVxPCHgDsANrWVgTO3w=
- Delivered-to: archiver@xxxxxxxx
- Delivery-date: Wed, 08 Jul 2020 11:23:05 -0400
- Dkim-signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/simple; d=gmx.net; s=badeba3b8450; t=1594221770; bh=HSryGbxTn4AR8feQieQuQK1LqVT8MKZAc9d2rEK7NP8=; h=X-UI-Sender-Class:Subject:To:References:From:Date:In-Reply-To; b=ENNYfqp4sp4TcPinVA6wGIXJridY41pw6CbkanC08UsFLgV/e8R/60WAndm2x7YOW VSGU+exQUD/iU/c+ugVwffqC5q0QO2EIR8CCHCyKb5nB0YFVw+3pB0+MbXYL6bBR4L zlv65XDSRDCnYAwI6gpJGPtl9FtoAfyC1q2kEfC4=
- In-reply-to: <20200708103542.GE2611@moria.seul.org>
- List-archive: <http://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-relays/>
- List-help: <mailto:tor-relays-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=help>
- List-id: "support and questions about running Tor relays \(exit, non-exit, bridge\)" <tor-relays.lists.torproject.org>
- List-post: <mailto:tor-relays@lists.torproject.org>
- List-subscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays>, <mailto:tor-relays-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=subscribe>
- List-unsubscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/options/tor-relays>, <mailto:tor-relays-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=unsubscribe>
- References: <cff8da7f-36bb-a987-f30e-aa93d3444399@riseup.net> <20200706110719.GC2611@moria.seul.org> <31a3836a-8787-7f4a-4032-d3fe45e002d4@riseup.net> <20200708103542.GE2611@moria.seul.org>
- Reply-to: tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Sender: "tor-relays" <tor-relays-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:68.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/68.10.0
On 7/8/20 12:35 PM, Roger Dingledine wrote:
> * One is dividing the network into known and unknown relays, where we
> reserve some minimum fraction of attention for the known relays. Here
> the next steps are to figure out how to do load balancing properly with
> this new parameter (mainly a math problem), and to sort out the logistics
> for how to label the known relays so directory authorities can assign
> weights properly (mainly coding / operator ux).
Which boils down to "subjective" versus "objective" criterias of a weight distribution algorithms.
Which is fine as long as the maths behind it is public available and understandable.
This would enable a relay operator to verify/falsify it.
--
Toralf
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________
tor-relays mailing list
tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays