[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
[tor-relays] adaption of a DDoS prevention solution
- To: "tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx" <tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Subject: [tor-relays] adaption of a DDoS prevention solution
- From: Toralf Förster via tor-relays <tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Sat, 18 Jul 2026 22:15:00 +0200
- Cc: Toralf Förster <toralf.foerster@xxxxxx>
- List-id: "support and questions about running Tor relays (exit, non-exit, bridge)" <tor-relays.lists.torproject.org>
- Reply-to: "support and questions about running Tor relays (exit, non-exit, bridge)" <tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Ui-outboundreport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:I8TkqWdgGTc=;DkFn1/vhbNeF9mNDBsFw5hIGbID NDenBHNeBOEg15vLnArgF1fKjmGlQ/EzfTK1uQKv0yPbPuQghVRPJX0sLq3+zFmsQDO7q+6So IHf8Pg2krkqfyNnxYVXifJNLn6rImgd40ba1KKi7UxWWY+UCvGJ99gqGnzmetPiIDv+6vAXpY kh6rlKE8QqajLK9JyBWDNFLvUvhY0IMKBjp0DAi1oUgyj3agnlbTkjKiYqHD3EIPTKf681S0d v9lObK/oQPYZiro0LUOehExrISdYYDs2mmDKiUunFXl6k4BsDJXSB6TDB0kzlUUDKaGyVTsgw Jz8O50A3EOcsT6qP3R27zGYiPuiTq8Cap1JvOI4U9t/0RF32PNAPuC8tfCU0Hj0+md6q3tu5Q E4/rO8U7GNjuqyj4anMPH64iOEDeyapJS3wwzPRryvZs5TU7v9GCSdzFF+xoaZq8SXWvpEy4a b4E9s4MMUzGpcaksnaequ9TRAolx1jrxmymZqy+JrJatpm71PhUXIhBcZUdfEf7GjMWGe8dxx HXy63PZe3NNMfQOSCP4Rik60bkr4vYbPogGq0SAmqtcKgFpRKDULtAwlrac1WOTREAFapP00c Yt6NyB/YEzcM8fTQHpdY4O77O3L77IU30u2PEaNzY0iUOJkxLXw+rLYbcvkBolvG4Pfh4Um4b VIXdT8bDJrBZHCYr3dudGLfyvRn27eKYg1QhMw+nTENaDDia1dzBzrnA9B8YTs5mjWzfUBLEQ L25KQayTMYSCYYJRxSfQ77JLyWuB78gm8JBWoeQFhcVOhx4aWvZd+byxTd4ne5yQNyeJbyisN qJYOdgp/R/qCHYxnS5qy9hIZq4aVBpVeLXs7wv15XLqt4qlDRzjOTewA6teil8690KogADJod 6UiwJ+lXbYpGjRMF8V0du1HoeytSDw3oK9vMo+LFQyF5kBm4mEFYHKKsnPIWfxHLo0GiBugNo C2Cttceguzxn5rRDD+DSU6ZDTrVT4W72iBmRN/LAYhEF2i4NDcC/x/f+6qt0ib5/gcDQnQ3yj Cnlk/gdHAe9+YhoSGddhhMz2hcTY7ksFHVi1f+CiK06KYgwZ4G7tze3enjiUlFaicGsRxsIkP G2GypdclYjVB6hpPYMuetfTpz+44IHUJyRyay+RmYQZ3Xhv7/Ksbxvgg5IRPvS1CqA58+ml1t gUgG66ItW1De2dm6MfI/yi2kfMsCsl1E8OAZFq2YGW8yneglOl62khWVq0blK4JRO8tZTyxzt EHtmPUGVrD3QGu/PdMalS+qr+PBm9hZU3iBbMK6zqDKLa3g6i8YeC3D7eaEdUdU5xC7yIACuN gH+KvvdfsbY8Oy/vEobYYm6o4mOIvKUxKre+nbX1/fU1pOnrnguqHOIO7dRi17mlhPmLeJYND pZIpQsCPMaz7FDYISc4yyYhQNDExH3HD0GEHTiQgj8KTjdtxEsWU9vZVZymdqnnt8cr+GyzjX NZr4LfsR6TNQo5l54IJbewlXK+Sx/glqHHaHME2ng/nTHnwPj0yrPBNDWd8GrI3cja3Z2EM5y cZ7aN+FJOeFGsaScTXP8NqkELAL2CHb4jrropMZA6USASSUbB4eyfUGzokVucHjfpGeKE3XnK edKApetVagJ5dHJa9IArNzWnJBCVWoZ9P0g+ZlopqwzudeSwy3FO+DzVckKvc7EpLzTqw9lrm veeuPVjlJxlIIFHZvlUI+KEJ6qXjGWpcgujgywFnZvqJXrMm+kuK9jy669B310bhDX85BtVL6 LeEIX1M70h44Mniq/2yTG5oIwckBd7nNW7M5fxIl3bko/UjK78UHB0II1z2tsllRnmNfbWI9x 9FSM8fMHvdQsAUlrfXMias3It8kDM6SRyoy0zSOjkoruS1PZfo2hW8C6gCBb5otPTkxpZ3zKh P7NiuJFAsrIrgt/oNwbIBjHiHO2dynxHxmi+Caxm7ypmKEFxj3KdJE81SS/y5BYUMRPDzNgNW 8x3U+V+nx2T6EfF6N8IVQFk6aRBHz3Pr6Sq7+6lEsaVyKVOO6277lNg8wvLx3TkHCytpRLbRS sgGn0Kj1GnyMSN44J3Oo9FIuKeOh9VaOJb4k2Ca5R2Z0d5RPey7xXnx53Oj3IdtAzzR0zAZMC Mq+fLFM2qZwwiJglpud24ZrFLlU7yaqAVm438oCBManJhYIV2KD2zXt1e0AdvpnFQKCb4RohL f/6vMx35kNfhql+xjqpcBYYHu75Cdk8aVuiOPsMM6+o4guSe4Njgxrpitkr4STeZvBuBEsplN WgwkAx68X6C+mZae5L/SyEGwREwz/HeKnXl1Q9l62oK/k0ljcXNMw7bHgbO7jyJXNk01HWfXt UTBrPxYnfiZ2micEirlrK86x7AZpFo2/9dp3LCEGU+UbekRmhAPPhbMcq9axJnEvH0DLUWURg KHtE3VrhGBOC2HAGXaDCZBxiUQ7n6MCBOhQjRjIWF27BDuwU0Nm3E2KkFisyVbsg1FwvIWowg nimIXz5Ne6cUOdZzm+UngXS3vA85YXN2k83yIArZS2c6XpwwHvSik3Ws1HJKue/SmOpgybg+g hwDas5STxlrNsIfyH4jAwogK3fr6R1xeYOOrfmapFU/6GPHLkQB48ejPZua/+XNLsOQbg+JNU TooF5tJrDywtKzPbJeuNnsVMxYOz4k8gcgDdRjrZNG4VdTMpWY7LHPDh+u7fhSyBI4MZr3/zw /g/heCkmHwbiJJbNJrhadjVqDHSEmBGdAxf2i0PiRt2TE/YB5ADzvHRP+H835cNGRQvUgv0EJ qpefkzOqF5DjgkqhsB/YATF4lavmtZB9sqvH0EqWghp36RRWiyS26/PQig19ztxb2wC8GjvKu MbE7xz+ouIqz69b/1Ga29GMI3xIyJoYc7om4M2dxLtCacVAYHm9k1A8hVZzxdejgKjQ9zG5d5 D34cD0pV6NUj+wDddWrL7nHFINkpxnvOfeo08aPvLlSrH7v7GRBwnNkE3gKvmEIYh98ESGk74 lhGI0nfuQTHykt0LbHrEgTpAOjPzFojs7T8MPElCIjn/TgAI7JTJipMG6Xq9FFo3C0EV1Bfvc aq/IZeRomM9bGXQrOA5hH7WxGqbguOZoHyEG0ijuMIiHvsNAR1mmKZ7xqbVdJRCpqL18jZi7T szcxMfxvZHI5Bpj2DBONqHaEAkuM/zx+mWknxPPpLrb2uLdrXf4dfM56pe+u1zvrwqTlcIKsJ 1XO5+7IzeWPQuEcc0mrzg3D+KpziW4SdZEQeIP3j8O9K1q9mDK/5Kc8bSWpkUMgtJiZRu4Xzf efWrYB/feRqXw4DFvP6DpN/twgY/5sVko3NnsG9KprgEVYe1VcpsNPB7ZOjlGxGzq2eFvNveC xV7NfG2Jg/zfv72Wr8pjgyxbU1TYe4LszAcVTqaWHIgrVTpFID/b8VewZEdv1NP0qUsTcMK5u LWpw1DSb5+WBEnz5Z1Wivj+hoH2jm6QajO530gKE8sEdBJ1OLk2NCpUA2zLkm2+JinrnDd9s4 mkt4mjIZEOIgWLAYA+n6ERaxPHG5pGG6iL+BxKKk/PnTw7nfdn4cawm/AMFNMUtkX7eORhxbs xuWYtpDsstDtK1Gomr5EMoQ3BIz/3fcSm55uojkrv52Sm2qibKh6V7vA154LQREJZlf0LCCsB CUqSymufCEOCRgbkSmtGMEc0dVnVxQ8LFgUUNux0ekv5Yx3O540GzWTJHcsa0+H8slGwJ8N5J l9eIXEI3bstmkjSXX+hmtyzcaNhsAf3TUz+gmXxWMuXoSyGv1mZzyG33JpsWQ/wIq2m1Mph4/ saJDFwM/kiUbXJsfBLQdDWhKU1QOkp1qA7I8GHJpw4LdpaVhfHXpffQkevzgMrQJx2KMIjY/u YAvtPVZlcMD2l67bsEE8keev/lNvdn/g5QnsuX50qBpY1VDk0lcRemxZWgR418q/GEgEfvlV1 Ux+itWYhdnzBKibQTkj4UPt1rDxpx/I+cFjoA/5bYrEOjVrlLiKW5y09i++gP5qVn3AEux+C9 zVsGHc91QAIKkslKZzF7iENXXNdVEmxXN0+M3fB+UlI8l9+dCZ/l9eJnC8xf90tmmrRYXGfWo l8Tl6CebviKpee7NvxYyViY86RQDeOOjtU56wIiYWAPqBUe1dIsb25H90GnuBmlC5jFfZHZsh KpD8dz4K1gFDY/Ombl4KbdJk04DRmr169FE5J7028OsCvCIkCKoS9PHL2U4Qiuzc7M12IEaa/ tIu8psQX9mkZHoa9evexkQa3b3jGcqkJ4zl2wUQWxJ8EalzNq0yQBxE+wQv6GZExnjR/ToZF2 Llnr578wWbRDljrqCnDdK8EIpR5hhzO02zT/g7ncH4hsl6VXeaOSl3Qn3r3bx6MZiNnvqgnR9 nJbFX65hu7KJAYb2/0u9t7uc5WlDjuI5kkxmOoh5aRVJs/z2U94N5tE+wCMQbRtAkzyqx+idt FbllEsI9S1F/p7pob+XpmkmRbvts4jPwKyBzso1T/Q85NtQhEkRnSENmL8MeU3D7XR85+3i/Y 2SuTeX3Zn/HPMp8iv/2GXdxdv79hlqRl+w5TVijwZk7+fHhv9fC4y+U1RsbiEIE3vHz3VW2Er eFQMmJZOy/9LS5CMR1//XjA99941UJ8oxltSY9QBR4QFl3c1cOV637fy8MM3JimKUaWfN8dtj CG0dbMJ0X+9DUceB9kdXzaddx9lDO9Nc5M6GuUARYiz3Mxc2hjwBu7J2AJnRNgMIdCoM1tIJ+ wZxFaqGIgPEzuphjh1Q/htiHPP5NJAf7nK5TqUepsftsWq14TRUPSS/00TClb+gTnA9Bo9cZs uujk+/x8DcCf2FUXmdQUQQoeJjyGTxBiz/eKLRGzF5cxiih8odUhnFwdjO3pOgxIXebP8e0Wg wzzwwFCBrddTHx0k5kydSeDw7jvQWzLgI5i43Wd1IKvTyknK+8DkEADku3Efsn/gMQwluTFBl XhgfIISMGtIQ0sCuXGuh/j89DrPrrzLlTqRqJdpj8E9DtOSgnttqTvdzv0IiC5zwo+Nhqfr5f ctkPRM8AauhiK/CBOaaKeR4fQwg8YMDlOoni13/12VG8MO+AmWXLDh+gPlhIZxl8Y5wZ9FciI 9nVR1cFdtpPRKeXr5bu8MChFu5drmEgHtZB0+ZcRmHjPxM6a6G/GcMt8ppbRvI1w3AVRHOc8g mXaVGJJSmEF/1Mb3NYxFT4nfimX5kQzovGn8zTNhJJUTOEh5TGr6y6/qosEU0NSMKJHYmZBme rmaXsMGbJfxhop2LZka3JC0LxAQYShJ/eGtcwNcvLOYDQn3ANv5LpyLPv6H30wrknZNbkePwS M+xnmIDIQgy52TyuVmhDDCvlTEjFI8WArFMg5uXe4LxK8M4vbI1UN1+KhTXRYbeUsCxYgcjrW MsBc8VhzJ8OLdoFynaPVTVXkgEO6Prdo0wjLJ7Us4k46dks+b3zVRhegXvAixa1+N/FkPYhYd SZck8NYhCntsaWEqbzWPtwtwGnovgUVKyylPoMJw/oPqkCilDXA731obp9L5DVRkyKyzay97D V1GlOTXHB/JGbbR2DdRfmA1sctR4wYuE5J4MAHHpRkbuNStl9WieNwwJi/xB9rlT0z27ETgCj 4dOD6T+CvwKDUm/KvB27694BUgWwPMk8JpsWTI2E3AqHi1oxVqWcHMh24tDKacQSQnmwi2fEi BO+Ymn7/zaxflg47v2KoZJlRrY6b7IqtDuYJ0U4cALbX+UHCApOgvQkwlAMog==
- User-agent: Mozilla Thunderbird
Recent DDoS attacks caused me to update the DDoS solution [1] and to
roll it out to Tor instances using [2].
The metrics below shows the effect for the (highly overloaded vCPU
before), the throughput and the amount of protocol violations of a tiny
Tor cloud instance:
Another example is Tor instance at a bare metal server, attacked between
12 and 13 UTC (no Tor metrics during that time) and again after 16 UTC.
The new rule set was developed between 14 and 15, and fully applies
after a reboot at 15:20:
The graph below shows that the ipset (which holds malicious ip addresses
to be blocked) was not updated at the first attack.
But with the new rule set in place it was updated soon at the 2nd attack.
The yellow line in the 2nd graph shows the portion of the change.
And finally the DOS Tor metric for this instance indicates that the Tor
process has much less DOS to handle than before:
I'm still fine tuning the solution.
[1] https://github.com/toralf/torutils#the-rule-set
[2] https://github.com/toralf/tor-relays
--
Toralf
_______________________________________________
tor-relays mailing list -- tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe send an email to tor-relays-leave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx