[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
[tor-relays] adaption of a DDoS prevention solution (now with images)
- To: "tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx" <tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Subject: [tor-relays] adaption of a DDoS prevention solution (now with images)
- From: Toralf Förster via tor-relays <tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Sat, 18 Jul 2026 23:37:52 +0200
- Cc: Toralf Förster <toralf.foerster@xxxxxx>
- List-id: "support and questions about running Tor relays (exit, non-exit, bridge)" <tor-relays.lists.torproject.org>
- Reply-to: "support and questions about running Tor relays (exit, non-exit, bridge)" <tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Ui-outboundreport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:hbSl+oBNIw8=;r0Yxl7WZJqdFTB0088Vld27Mr/j LJ2giEawHjwoE3pUzYmtFVoCgyJ3/7apIBZBlj9CKQXzV6L/fKJ+DBfp5PiSyWB0Jjzt0ladi 1XIn447KiBSS8bB2cgleFXEj8gPxglq9Y8BXUAuYEM2hFZ1v5Vjiv7KRG0jCsf89EHaQEcaf1 ik04xWRfWWCENQ9GgiwSInCy8WCohYfs2AiWICG/o5DN0VG++x10ZBBhJtVJh7cuFALOJmsgf YYxWwfqh53KTd8Jbmnn1CIcMa9UjhjjdJytEjwFPFopBpkxpisoZjAEUt93WnLAkcpuQBY6fn k27F/MJJ+eAQ13OXIbbG+ub6cu5wy+GysaiedoXfj4RdDm2vyJuYr+Qhn1NIS2IEsN18vZBVk HsT5DnkW+r7IPHN4luttV/QIGXV4s3VGsEegVZTIgeyCFuFhL00oRBXZMTllp2ZJiKg7ITGAd XZWGj8odSoQCzu4RIHmWmPuXonQxWJBlHveWuXoERZebc+OJbmOnMZeROcMH8apKx9oQQFh9d XPusLkvd9qftOqNM5x+0PSgttswq0pKrg5f3vvrLvYppX3+s65dlUsic7HHwUu+9/8mQCoCAV X8cA3xBQlDLnlrZy1MwS+iniLIyypG4LtGLz6HvCqU5LzcMRcJ72fu+nTWdbTrocqFtdl2Lbd gkJWGrt+XPmTN1CwvN0sUu6N6SiX/R91kDASBBYpaHfTy9IBYNDiWzj6nxoEBSJAQ7HM0dsmR aGtGldZKQSZj/bhrVbcKFh7DtLk4BMpDWQbq3sMf4pcmNwCifHB0Y162YvEIw6gk69Rwed0zr DIeCdHrgAU4jm1lrweUZ6+inqy5YNaznQbQy9cmjy5/BiOuqUgqhdM4SJQSPrGOqiy/yYKF1n UwkD8x2vGPULo4H+52hiWA7v81PPxgXQsO1N0nXazB+F5BFc8fO2OHG6XS4iy3bQym+WzbLbJ xxdxoWF+pCuzweowUFDKvx9s6sbdZzEOiAQzko2FdV1Uf/vbyTTgI/nyRFI9fQPXVGqCgDA3O tws6x+UkUEJr8cuH9nEaWeFguLcqdy5EaE+LnoyMDKhnSMc76UP+okjjTP+EGYq80U/RHa4/x KhoW4R8KT7U10kyad49BGJONWS20L8HewGbzNAtWKb9WQNBKu+jf47b26i0Al2B4KmvubYfHR VMtSzO0Lk0zBGatyh8HCQXlwnhUmIUKY3KtrLY1rBXuHAX/3dbg3GgPWEit0T6mzvqyrNhsuS W2w8PLO7PHtfWPbqPSll0TYL1Y7OkBkEkTe5xM/QzwIBVmFZlFXFpjNSe3gH1vOLEZyHmgpVZ KvlpM0ETtS4qZRAV7BQAIgDNar+iejlg3i0/R4M/UKWqlz4x6Oy119l1ZUSIxXjtdmNhaO/GK flm3cpK5LKq6elXSAw4ZIeO2VjbXmeuSXVqnW4+9XZG3q/VKXQLdOENQ2hxQT5wdTlXLihkDo zDb1vA1y0/T8M9+0aGYjGn+D3EjawIgSLqUv2+LVK69FMv3mUzZpmK1Re+QybgG7tnKqD+3xF FIOJf2TKI1eq+NMzvT+SqsjjkNhCRZfQN8CWGWJw4EYC5GvRZ8DjnJgAccrrIVVfNacIL+41x yL2yfaqZ/Bo2/4+6GQBKI4/Dl0Eq4KMLfx1uMmmkSX1FfBJhOF9oFsTixOCYFMYEM39z3Pz48 Jz/l2wpd86hnSl1yV8ZYajdFcIWCUkxgCpiUkrEWQYTzDE0D3irIzG0b4+9vzG50AcMOYOvWB XzemDrlt6N4GhVFSRFu9S5J4wCtLWpjKzyIq9rxv876CfcNaUJoR6rNFscHyGbJsXZsceUSBg +NuTv+RX7AvakiJ8Fxwed4ZbFIaGICkGS9Ncs6MeQmWN69B2TGishNZsj9OYhx8oEsoZPE0Nx mXEYtzoW1O+V+Cj+vzkVpySU2NGUxK0wQ/eLGkvwBsvbQY2TBVq2/e+p0DPvZqB6SXzyDK/T2 xy9ohSmMNLroMkdoREycpOT9DTbDSrKWcWHX5nvDoEinaRFeNYwSRzdmHmQ3DKnLCrF9i92Ai gW2PEcyy/tCfGxKEGKFRWDa+/2hPIXyeo4UT6uGhbxAKS0Xu8ZZM4jbvhO42MqcCkjKKmxu4T T6YmVg9dwaHwh5LTmzuVxWU8Nmop9nNBtHK9CyqZ3bW+GaWCSkOQCafwM2g4MSOZQCp4bi9F1 FdGbI2AKqg1kQfk2IuwgUWaKvKFXgl7uWCxWsXtkgFRtjY4ncgZwraK+uZMdZ8cYoYBMSTzw9 wmo/nMuUSWaDGiB5XqHBYYlLs/PL9joWnAKqGzcSvmOE7RH7N2vERwH+MnrtdrbUwr5eXOoHt bifBuJ+Bd0G82QBNsb1ZXVbJVry2SYsqaAEZQybBxvrlQmPCWClWk9iUKG9rNiIDKPLEXbP+b d1dzyGHbug6AV9f0q2gQ/mQ1d7x4XegtG5qxNZLvvbcRso+PP5YZqwRGB6/w1+AzLcETJF+ZB MLvE9K6nGjBB0EWDt1pS0a8g/Riteut95l0zY2aoQ3iAOZBGyugewTnQQeeXJYJY92EpguBaY tLj8RX/bsqPHMmjD65ZjPPWmYfwjgJbSRaL3I/WDoiO2eVxsNxncGsqWm9g/AOXuxfUDbHugp /CRkA0dENNpxqhWY3VzC+jg1vWsg0+P2k41jVklO+hqi60+u6xWZ31pleFpvh/WIlUhkuQWJ/ CPZD6Zx0RQh1z13h4CdNbXu40FcQVqLg9ux4uPNqlA9x7DiJo5X0XYdVctzJIaZlGggovgxbQ 1ZhVRExzoYoK/eaYCmUxcaMadt2des/blmrVkA00KzZi7VaGcWRIs3LNjW9jGZi3lDE6iFTrY X0C27t3FZq+qk511ZnvOXTNRQQk1st88rkHiU3iy7Z/gF2ZTSVsep7/ovLyxnB4PTtFTQjmqd b4r0JMU8dhi+iRPbwGjAlhu9FR9gVFNeVVtHUUZGTD2FJJULVTJP3D65fwoenbhX/24KOligb Tx+M4pRYSbBZCukAOegce4CjQUI8as2XJpzUCaeLYeLP5jjyMDGxzmqNO2G1i5Yul+abqopDB HwLuXeR+AgdL5i1oVM1YZ5GarTBZiZ4INHSqomrbPxy6+zrC7g0YUcaWE/390cF1Bk6vIwO57 4WcWlYhsww4R+5VNleN8XsTx9YEKfdB9LMR9PnuGjs0MtNosdWWOUu5qBSAOyEbaDj2pzpAW2 TlZmBLl4jxXiuK3bd7WkLkf1+zsnSEcfCsf27bwQHDrPu4acJ4s76Waa8U0sc6bMG8mxzmv3y 5r7Qdo7w3/bxc9puQWBAko3wNM9EILLPNqT6xqfaHBM7GzKlyj/dhH/t/U7F1izWEXZaFa0Mp AVLmCGJo3JrvX3/uM4IzG8goBDhaxH/jklV1F4TtPMQ5gVZhq3EgiEN+DMEkrhSX1/Gc3Vfpo MfET2sqOMrer+rFnzEP0zc8PsknPjpf+zhqDcjVTk55uDuOe1vaH1ulK6tKsRpfJC/JHAGwtY bM+HXj6zSBvvPk7fOTQtcPwFEkCGR8Z10uE+pUVxS0N2yGdi9svpnGxAYT4FSoSFjwbgT9DzT za8raYALv8c8tu2blByhtN22rZmiBYaHqAiH6H7QspZMWu0m+GszyEatkWOlI1+RIjwsM5bBd cHkY/EJQlpZAtnF714C8UNXzQGDrrtIHwjODk2MEq3PEm0HMLNQtgKGSNRn2zv0JVLg/T1ZwX OmQVJt6nRdHjNmKbztBFNduJeKp29s3Z7hRmg0j8fjlk/YT6yUKihvPMHVhmn4QpDz4TuhGPb UJeNpZLP1pT7IzgpPCf/ghmbnOt3JYT47ThFE26ep2IIAXRLK89oaR5GKs4dj5qL5TiDxrtSN NeOYjLq3RZ6wYI1arAI66JgPyGkp6CB9rXWwP1WDfcfOcBAFLoNKfPqm84BVrR153a2dR6035 ojsK+N6WVNYLN3ZAxdfQyAUgYIslFM1Am7ZlBInPH0GwywcddYe+WsDMtW+Cc5JVdL9Ivy1AK O75Tdk8Mw6g3vA1w+/JAEIUdYo33TImFbVYWsjAUadoDAvA3aiYrVIBVuSybgoeaNJUhKt1iI /duRVYGnxJatLc0pdLAJIOsGMQ5qs7htzQHUR6m3LNz/C6wQ9RZtqVwVhiV6PqSjHsAuVY13b d7eWLLe0CSM9XSVDYdZurpsNYr41kXw3k1pxo9FvGE7FIHMiEGejeamvgFYqdufqtU5mxJwNT DV/CJI+kEm0iFXTKoAXt5IGYgF1uMepRuRz88NEBTdctEskaNkwFfJZiWY6+vyhFJNYg3SdV0 k3uzILbKVaSpP8MgB/pjnWJ0SglBCger8cNMhGBAeN4F6ZnPOPsYUR0Cm3xs4TrwegyV19qF0 9JUmrmM+ufHCiMcRE5shTOBBIK9rtEhoHpEq/6ZuiUkg/zN2d0oXKwGUjRi5324VYfdScC3j+ EKg3e7l7zNeLujuWtb9VGFA2TYiZb5lRAF1NR/F2ylio0+am/AaSjYTGzbyhZvGmGYRVF8Awd U2Gjr/HU18IjYVjd0SQjj0XDxLD5AJjtvoD1FGiV8FAGOrYmQYrzBv3D6tc+bI5bnn/9CCtfF o1XzXEMgQ2EWPcZK7VxYWmpqSjK4X+VZRgb4pJc16DALb801TXP6EQHnafLnmBNRy30ROwj6J XFD7dY0zAZU1L0tNdyUZNqYMZI6vaCgtlmDnDnQblgQFIDd45pu51viN4EXxvU9dWnHIRhC51 pAW5shiFZfUStZYA04qImWcV3iT2IglglbJWMpZqgp3dBN5yGxWt8utKrvPh8aOAT3pEUM3D0 LbsRbLGER0ytjPJND+8smoJBh0eZJ08PCLxqNbBOSGaN9RAudERC2i6jMQ3P5G4b8mxcR5Yir OxAP77oMbEEQGatEzbtM3dCLKqGVXO7RXmHU8eZNNYBd8x4kUuTpCKQZ0zcF6lpQNAtb206Lt SQVweeCcAlmKrnVO//6DGZXZqJSLVGLymfbD3+eujC5hSs5bXGsp2vtZiQBOkRqU+6924q0H8 l8fZiY6zT3OzmmydKNz7T5cYiPw7MVv7Nr76Gs4JvvNzDUss+GxMG7N6WIcF9VZeCAX1haF6O 4nRHhkcwG12dympgM6SF39hsPOyfz79lisuEvU5wY0ZD0NjdZ+W59TE7EwpRmL9y1U6cEyw/1 1WtcCDZEi4p7trvjgb1nooDgsVU60doedhghxbgJJbWeGvf+SKtV335Tejz3jzNBYiWYYHlWx 7xNt/coRYJ/TKKQOcgZwiSWX07Rr2+/5f1MhNA8dtvW3M4rfuN9DYnEpKuTi5h0zT1ReOyq2I IJ53Jm/C5QxEAgQsBLb1PDr1l51IlMMEuEM/k1GJJ+xYA7FsSRj498XgU/kOF63L63uaHe2UR r54bsyQb2IKeSp9qFNXWlFCmHi/Jx2/7G/oyutZsMReLb8D1jU/OOXNP78tSef440PkxHwWTu vFWzaBfelSmxyd2YZxlvgk07W5XWsahGlNnFn/F0xkXWGBS/U2JCchmZBbI7QH+PDWSkZ9dDz CDFaCgmCvm71WXQ8J2tePj4gPesquzFH6ulZ25olCUQmTFgGA2hDtg/EPWay68T/hH7eUnFO4 BZWTzIGCjHkCMu9j/KAX5glPRHvVsjpyfC/sGx56Ojlf7U8xx5b4ReQwKrPvpoSHNlzgvSRNp DRG+2HH/vjtVPZIJzEep5mEyeHwXSn0Zn5nTHbqjFcRwQTw/miyNpoLQFmeXbLcfOQhKgTGaT wV3W7gngUOKVUSoz3THc2SRrfSLsma313QHoNsMCXg/K1CQpumuC0qtsf+bSw5EYakxH+z+4L Zqcw++b6Bud/Ic0zYCN1c6dCir+nwYudzIPYofXpK+0Sa9E2m3PiuAa1swm3GUSr9SjHuWZCm 8D3xRusbGZVUiC2zL2udjgRLHfTjvKe1jLSJmALCUK3uWveOfOjY692i2z49XgGMmvSaie36K +ejPnY72zxVZMIle4L7wLaUggpHS9nIN0L8G8meAQEBrEprfPKzhq6LWION9L7jnNDlzbpnJq WjdFLacJ0G5WbF3K1KeUd7VgPO6NP7/kfdVX4rhoka14mx7vX+46JYfunNWar5L/PoIM0vA/I YAwDUGwXW9TvLTuU/Cq/16uDD1/SZvbgMIjYKzNkjB+NVmF9GiuvPkzUZmf+aPveOzidb0Q==
- User-agent: Mozilla Thunderbird
Recent DDoS attacks caused me to update the DDoS solution [1] and to
roll it out to Tor instances using [2].
The metrics below shows the effect for the (highly overloaded vCPU
before), the throughput and the amount of protocol violations of a
tiny Tor cloud instance:


Another example is Tor instance at a bare metal server, attacked
between
12 and 13 UTC (no Tor metrics during that time) and again after 16 UTC.
The new rule set was developed between 14 and 15, and fully applies
after a reboot at 15:20:

The graph below shows that the ipset (which holds malicious ip
addresses to be blocked) was not updated at 12 UTC.
But with the new rule set in place it was updated soon at 16 UTCk.

The green line here is the (now first half) of the changed rule
whilst the yellow line reflects the addition for that rule.

And finally a graph of the DOS Tor metric for this instance which
shows that the Tor process has much less DOS to handle than before:

I'm still fine tuning the solution.
[1] https://github.com/toralf/torutils#the-rule-set
[2] https://github.com/toralf/tor-relays
--
Toralf
Attachment:
OpenPGP_0xC4EACDDE0076E94E.asc
Description: OpenPGP public key
Attachment:
OpenPGP_signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________
tor-relays mailing list -- tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe send an email to tor-relays-leave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx