[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
[tor-relays] Your opinion about tor-node.org
- To: tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Subject: [tor-relays] Your opinion about tor-node.org
- From: Martin Gebhardt <martin@xxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Wed, 2 Mar 2022 00:57:26 +0100
- Authentication-results: rw0b2d; spf=pass (sender IP is 45.153.160.137) smtp.mailfrom=martin@xxxxxxxxxxx smtp.helo=[192.168.178.183]
- Autocrypt: addr=martin@xxxxxxxxxxx; keydata= xsFNBGHx25kBEACa6X8shMQ7JFK8vjeqN46vdxlKTSnGaFkYF1/DnRB2Gly7Ec/jH3xTriyi SgZ91UEq+KIs4VfW0u8axls/0t0lGxD0CRPWYpbGccEODWLVM5SiZNvvS9YWXmkakEX9pL4g lF7v5sV8N/YdgODljaXz/vHa+lgyQtSeozKkudSDC8wafjR14A859P8fjlEbTdIkIhdJF7Gz Ltzl2T4sIiJhWjFgorZzXqkvQShHIQdoz72Ckx6roh9r4ZVJjl+BYInMYBErH829bmGqWVF8 JOC80dAGyaoJtRzBqjsI/pYucFJI5fdNeycSdoMBD88TlXnMf9a2xxbckrYyVaxQFVrH00Q3 EWsL19/mH/N9sJ8bOe9yk9QmYuh1MVbpS4zlKXGHeXlyhuvItqLBcwECcVQHUSJJwyRrfTPJ s+cNfwMKMRoSTtt2l6peYka6RjjvORoPDfJpSmmKtW5DTueL+nTLplJVqpczteLqmCuXlTni GDpFRXUBkQ4aeJI0Kij6NNGoVDUT8cWNBL6fX9LoSoBM1rDNOUQYhM884HTB5r1fafG/kFau /b4LvJnWpqQLBcEHGVrlQFubdN6j76MxwOunIk6DE5sk24zSPETH/teHXNDm2ef1Rq1KWjRl 7k5YImYS/IjO1NHy4QOP84PW8EI7BGUoN7+QYro2eLHJX9ljAwARAQABzSRNYXJ0aW4gR2Vi aGFyZHQgPG1hcnRpbkBnZWJoYXJkdC5pbT7CwZQEEwEKAD4WIQSFI5W9lyjNFzLshN5Ucrhm 6mzT3QUCYfHbmQIbAwUJAHanAAULCQgHAgYVCgkICwIEFgIDAQIeAQIXgAAKCRBUcrhm6mzT 3f57EACXx0W9+0LJ2Ho5XaWCdlS4nAQ7h6htAIw7tDe+Zg3MU00bKZbjP4cjYlk4k6C1urwA JtA0ljMXb84UOgeT8A51uGUiV0OjHWSBqUdd2FUg5QDE1oAzPbsXKk7gHo+n6DnF9ZteezDN K5SQrrS7Gb3Cu5wPIiq3JByzClF955sTupduHD1dbU11UQ+JwX7ZiElPo+XZjQBqr7PkYl2K CMpc4Hzl90o0ciPqkyMrC3dg6SMSMA9B0LnpL57U1QYioSa38aFvChTBy35h1p6nEKCEKYGD xRlfi1qDNOkMSM5TaoqseZDO2dKNK4W4Y9hku4G9dwGgGetMyYBHFnUDxglLxOa3MwCPvTo+ znoeKCUjWgi7Wq/wuDNTqozjdbkhrRaxd8GOQ1vK+vaFMvm+Q8BUKPv9bTdxSULH3078xej8 fAoupBtuVBVv7TAaO/uwnV135w3XppQ70UhNa4HUSCRGRD3oLsHVQcZt/MIGIflVZwN1aiXG CARa/PkHVN0d15vvu3YeaW6y3O9/nfHJbGqqQyw48Ha2dzjPtLafslM2y0cFw0sKXn8xPoqp 5xe/Mc1vCYybX1f2Ra+xYsxRTAyr3S3OsDSuh9GQyd7y20IfoeoNiSpNf+bV0AiiCbwEDDgn IQscmg+iWcsgBqZq7xm/fe7yeIn/X72b4WpxsRodIs7BTQRh8duZARAAoU2CilswGTrRpXqF j0cxVIhFO9N1BFZkCXnQ8m5KDCC1Iuj8e/6S8bi6CRRhai9Gj3B7/A6YAba4Dtf9gPxY31WK 2LrN8bo51GA19Ld5Qnt4j0FMi8SP0h9V4lIFz4ibgXIAeB2EvZo5WadFWX9Qa3wZYAAbjvxs +vkhWkCF9ztoI7eiZscatSDBVhrcG4t1N0wT2ykccwcdHKimiLNUdp+SJotVVBxTrvGgToX5 6tkh0V9LxVjjej46j4Sv2i0OFnP5V+3/8X3BgkORYcHE6G/h0G4xEMNf25DckMtJztE2SWfG /FL1eFRmv/GybgFS323OPwBd/pGXXDhNgQHG6OphRdSky3k+vD7aMND82pchIaIkvyMO98Xv fUObrQCnz5tbVvhL5PnhPI/MjfLRr4DexHOiWLR2knLYs3ov13UKfnPkpgv05j76RZgIxAHA cwQj5FL8rtY330LoVZ34edF8RA37rY7S2vnK4fsCYrePdDj7etX/eUv9aRQvj+0dOmfu/Yoi P2Cw48I1WSPjf4plkuw3aprwT13uBGyKMc7prC95gjQRiO4tiyLrmQQyF7AThvmrzLRcE36q C5wp3hrH2mE2I3FXoaL7q6ziiV2FE6gLUS5us5LAItr/DXiiMiAsDwxjvjbufPFEP/4Lii/5 o3b+iD3CUMFRdACgkIkAEQEAAcLBfAQYAQoAJhYhBIUjlb2XKM0XMuyE3lRyuGbqbNPdBQJh 8duZAhsMBQkAdqcAAAoJEFRyuGbqbNPd0PIP/1go0j6D384gyLlw+lZ2I6ue5ir7aD3LWCXu zxfbzsqQ4ZJ0QXzkIz8WyUAsCBKclspFtELvFrc80GFPsrLcu5FxT+Ojp4g04n1DhndKveUR nv2FFKiKgrEeQA/zuN8ZSK77BXGGAbL8Yjptxv2cMaZFIlbh9M1pd1v2Az5AnxNzWusCknjr JFjUez2Z7s/9dhGUJjnscrOnMgGuM84DsprHnpofYeP+D4yZOyMRInpNKvnA+OgBz0X5A4MJ Bu0D1wNmYWRo6c2PrasIFhaMmInpLI0O6GMG2MWpBMEkKgfwr+iwswJ7NpB6fY3hw/ByAizH 3U80Ik9Q2Le+L4ELx7tmaZnQIwIZiDh/juKiKrDqFEaGmoPit7cx4WYj1JM8BVYS3AGyKSeP gweyG8geH3GUbTrxxpb7Qk8i7Rk9jX92B0ugmfz/fhqCfo4PkRrF/uUNlneHI65P+1fXgs5k INwuGewf6fBgOzrkn4F7HPLAKAHmUNuJAszT0vbm6D1e4wJ+2FvF9Q5P0aGNhX5zAsLT6s1T Z4Df7IE0cmaKc+b8Z4O5vJfT1NdlJfuIygBu1/KoHnaUISJqv7iibJoLT6tFK6O20PfayF3+ akmzGBdGxM8A1rXN8226/h9cqadMzFGWFaOeVyG1gqfu8vbrGqQfjJ8BROeDWqP8sx9t6Fjy
- Delivered-to: archiver@xxxxxxxx
- Delivery-date: Tue, 01 Mar 2022 18:57:57 -0500
- List-archive: <http://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-relays/>
- List-help: <mailto:tor-relays-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=help>
- List-id: "support and questions about running Tor relays \(exit, non-exit, bridge\)" <tor-relays.lists.torproject.org>
- List-post: <mailto:tor-relays@lists.torproject.org>
- List-subscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays>, <mailto:tor-relays-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=subscribe>
- List-unsubscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/options/tor-relays>, <mailto:tor-relays-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=unsubscribe>
- Reply-to: tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Sender: "tor-relays" <tor-relays-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:91.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/91.6.1
Hello all,
I don't know who of you is familiar with this, I just came across it a
few weeks ago. It's about tor-node.org.
It is probably a person who collects funds for the operation of Tor
infrastructure. Nothing wrong with that and I applaud that.
What you might find objectionable, but I don't, are the sponsors.They
are marketplaces that make their money from drug dealing and other
illegal sales. I don't mind that, anything is better than buying your
addictive substance from windy guys at the train station.
But what bothers me is the transparency. I also believe that using Tor
is an act of anonymity. But running Tor infrastructure is an act of
transparency. I am very interested in knowing who is working on our
project.
Unfortunately, the operator can't come forward here either, because then
his anonymity towards the marketplace scene would be over.
On the one hand, the operator justifiably wants to remain anonymous.
Just to protect his sponsors. On the other hand, however, this leads to
the fact that he can not reveal himself as an relay owner within the
operators.
The operator can also not disclose to his sponsors what happens with
their money. Because then the sponsors would know which relays are
operated and then it is over with the anonymity.
Without wanting to imply it, I think that this can also simply be a
fraud against the sponsors. I wouldn't care about that either. But I do
not think that this is the case and assume that relays are operated.
What do you think about it? For me, it's a breach of the principle of
transparency, which I'm sure most of you here agree with.
I would like to emphasize that I welcome every supporter of the network
and I am glad about every single relay. But do we as a community welcome
this kind of relay operators? Feel free to express your opinion.
--
Martin
Attachment:
OpenPGP_0x5472B866EA6CD3DD.asc
Description: OpenPGP public key
Attachment:
OpenPGP_signature
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________
tor-relays mailing list
tor-relays@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays