[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
Re: [tor-dev] Anti-censorship discussion with Briar devs
- To: tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, Georg Koppen <gk@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Subject: Re: [tor-dev] Anti-censorship discussion with Briar devs
- From: Nathan Freitas <nathan@xxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Wed, 27 Feb 2019 13:12:08 -0500
- Autocrypt: addr=nathan@xxxxxxxxxxx; keydata= mQINBE/X27MBEACulyj4CfeOClOxZ2/tS6qnwjN8xQCVb7kWAS3yiMaXZ3oTcsay2njap1p4 twkdjJ3CS+4HrAnFlxE1PJYYjTYyWMwswB2sO/I3AFGNQlJVN4pS4EEuOpbXJU1ULg/qW6dl LAWCo1OAzbU2Qp4ABspp1bbmjNIxCIqIyRlVmaE9Ti2bABIWGpr7RbOYOyZ1OUDSldFnxns/ MNKGnLXAUCTVPKHzkGvyTHjhnJEN6f+u9pYs7K+0vCsxJSsdh6viUoDCFa9RMRI6OB8XpqHV 51MVh2ZRTChWRBLeZujS5CfYmlJGABWRx27LYgiYB7bGqfY5d0R1eFpsFscEpYxfWSHeQX61 JiiFBduPyvMrsw2bDhjhDzk6ahK9aIRfJDexVVnw2hQTVClsm85J1COuDoY66KDIstu9lxv5 aSl2auLtcmHTKLD1FaDaKjM5QaaTjZ0251KiunrUKk7xXgvyw2rbeVIMqik5LAZnAl0V8TDC uW7MueySRedndvKTcf6Swgm6RURcAe39q80dmcgxhXvj0/8YELUoZWLjsbjcsiQ2DuQ4vnY1 rCGRT0QJwEhYiKOaq1gTeTa/BKYcd2MI63oPz2cwQx25bQutVuMnozm+eFP3oK9kt08XpZvG 7ysSMa/Qiyx639Mb3bEAkaJDEF9BwaEjUexAaibNdXcQEcP8TwARAQABtDhOYXRoYW4gRnJl aXRhcyA8bmF0aGFuQGZyZWl0YXMubmV0PiA8bmF0aGFuQGZyZWl0YXMubmV0PokCOAQTAQIA IgUCT9fbswIbAwYLCQgHAwIGFQgCCQoLBBYCAwECHgECF4AACgkQqAEYPmmzeqmQNw/+I0SX EDEyNqyfT7EWK1zcgtmGz8pDDmCwASdInBIPM0q72eaP31Aj5Pwflqe5FCyYlobEBcvWYqQ7 ejqCQhPgLB+gh0vIwBSKfZ8JiYsDGANInf/KzIo5MbOWx0Q/h9E1XvqXg6RT4O9xzxcAwFVI 7geC1qwZw02eTC4XK3UuSZ+0woGdwqjB+OBha9u5CazqKJT1lkQ6m5zTh+yb6eDKHUQA7YEN A86qjlrh+jtL6tXJK8qEK+GN8V17FJWWqWztvLOtcMradMB4ZsbdTsmCgrIVBPT9XD9PRkO1 jxVWVe2da1sJJnc7egeO5ZyCrXQU1Bjyz1z/r2SnSi5y8MAb7KE+B23iI7HWCfSU3PqEZgqW sBZfyfJ8JRHRVl0KB4gnsfKdjcEGXWkiXace28E2t6HYvJlLJWXqKO45AgblFx9bgVDWgkYc QvNBbquc+cG5t8fq6wOTIGT+j+wa9urt19etpx3TZoRO1UlBTyu1HA7PJO77VIfWUTymwk2E tKYKthOLc4As97ID6kXLoWaxarESrlayG3OJezUl4EY+8H7NKx3JSwmra9lnHgQatXU7iULk YLl5bzgE9twcgI9w0BKo3DHMg9LxTyPY3fzEu36PIYgGCLbXr9pS4FoFmtSjt/N974Qeyvlm 8KkBDwmlMAdpJzktH67NiyKYk89Aho+5Ag0ET9fbswEQAMGiVLrDZaAy8eA1z4hNGTtPV+im C64PvmYxDM0aMs3ZZs5KbOQxuCsghVR2ICtLg0zQmikENpfA4IsHjTJNh94sx5Fc7+6hmWCA TWySgPgiwag0w+pcBicQgNNbIrSJwtOlRLEFwd6+lb2piUE0duqldMRa0F0POpMX6cYN6IMq h0SEkSKs5Ko0SzSFPLWDUeHQSwf7dBbR800IEJMo3mxlGIUL9eDZ23gpQjPbVqyZAunrBzFf uZIlzMsriNptHnlO3f8B7iMzYSqs+8Ljthke81UTZO7wZbZTQOpEe6FCSF38N1uEpRqMCW/G eLoDO0aOe9Soj85AFY2Mhs+sSkJGIz+afx6By/JelKalYMzPnZjemJFokzlUcQBA/xlZka3z w1bXMvp5E3y3k/hnE1Lgx2HaaSPzqFjnle3lQKLHr9EvkCCGWPGxjCX8YZpLiKNKeiCSMmU8 IblIkte/XQKCKFnSgHiGVuHIzDaR6PDY2WqKjTKgWaB/yqhULWpAabZGd25fjbYhOkvSgraz ffqKw8+wDRGcw9sfi219Cx/qdZtGeK5uBf3Xh68f7JszH/2vS/FiWjB0gl1MKv9ePRgydRgY 5rCcaNZVmUKGJVOvDE9EQwmq3uiLmgcPcSxLSpFkrLELpo5uuUjOP6FE1ocwGNifmdNpNNGE wR2H34H/ABEBAAGJAh8EGAECAAkFAk/X27MCGwwACgkQqAEYPmmzeqkRVg/8C1N+VP4KBW3M tjcA+78e2gZMvX+4OnFiZ53dWb06STkh9b1GccPy7T+5/JQyK6OGwVIIEWz5tPWVa2XgoahC ENjFa2RsDCnCr0iIxiUm5mB6j2GP8Zkch5VvTcBh2yORKR963FoWJio6O2p2n1VL0xqy9DMb Sx/OieqJ3y/qwAtVgf9+nAzyVsLoJTYKa42eL43j22lDue7s6oCMzmK+GdIDrRGEgN2Fdd/J d993OsmjSpw1dpIF5JaTlpBUKczM2N3WNbWLZtjx30XcyhxzXYkiXPv7nUvuJhD07MH8HPvY 9M+J1Uuc218txO4eylGc5jQPyGdewIb/Uf4AYCWAle0j1KXFEntaA18CSBXHukswWZCeq6vk g2V5HdePPFNdS0qnp/k57TGjJKMaNK4HVVj4C1UOeW47I9U3eoSuvCYlJObi/D6BozRBezRx RMHM02fUnib4+O6AOi8zvRf3OGT5OZGfUESyCPHMJJJLAXn3pSJ/dlMHsRuNtrMUtZpIKGBK kD+tNWTeqKSdQLlMyoOb+vBHSUtxiIjo/MkicpxyiM0P0MgEhQWERbVIxmX2D8ya7gUN6EtO p9KGzwYtJb1PbBymTXepEgIRCTr0zsvvOOmxVHDMUHbCEUFm3ofBthB4puKe/poAEzOWXFNL THGHDVKtjh0i6ywxCAQTL/4=
- Delivered-to: archiver@xxxxxxxx
- Delivery-date: Wed, 27 Feb 2019 13:12:27 -0500
- In-reply-to: <4a08252f-2aaa-92a5-33c6-142188312cee@torproject.org>
- List-archive: <http://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-dev/>
- List-help: <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=help>
- List-id: discussion regarding Tor development <tor-dev.lists.torproject.org>
- List-post: <mailto:tor-dev@lists.torproject.org>
- List-subscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev>, <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=subscribe>
- List-unsubscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/options/tor-dev>, <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=unsubscribe>
- Openpgp: preference=signencrypt
- References: <639cbe9c-0814-9fd2-6a13-8f09140bb898@torproject.org> <9405a2b2-d6f3-e83c-96eb-add13f412999@torproject.org> <25fc2bfc-1546-eddf-5995-e809b13a2253@grobox.de> <4a08252f-2aaa-92a5-33c6-142188312cee@torproject.org>
- Reply-to: tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Sender: "tor-dev" <tor-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:60.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/60.4.0
On 2/27/19 4:54 AM, Georg Koppen wrote:
> Torsten Grote:
>> On 2/26/19 11:19 AM, Georg Koppen wrote:
>>> I think we should be able to provide that with our Tor Browser builds
>>> once we have all the PT pieces sorted out (which is rather soon).
>> That would be nice!
>>
>>> So, probably the easiest way would then be to just copy the respective
>>> binaries we produce over to include them in the Briar software
>> I assume these binaries are reproducible?
> They would be used for Tor Browser which has reproducibility as a hard
> requirement, so yes.
>
>> We are currently not including these binaries directly, but publish them
>> as a library (gradle/maven to jcenter) where Briar and other projects
>> can get them from.
> Okay, good to know.
It seems to me that Tor Browser should instead perhaps rely on the Briar
build process, at least for Android. I will be switching Orbot and our
AndroidPT library over to the Briar dependency in the next release.
We should also figure out who is doing the source builds, how these are
published as public modules, and who is monitoring and verifying the
reproducibility. This is for both PT's and the current tor-android
binary project that I manage (https://github.com/n8fr8/tor-android). It
would be great to have Tor to be the source for trustworthy binary
builds, available through direct downloads and gradle/maven/cocoapods,
etc. We have talked about this many times in the past.
Related to this, we are also building and publishing PT's as shared
libraries, instead of binaries, which is eventually going to be required
on Android for both tor and obfs4proxy. It isn't all quite working yet,
but will be soon. At some point, we'll have to talk about that whole
transition.
Our goptlib shared library build project is here:
https://gitlab.com/eighthave/goptbundle which is being made available to
app developers here:
https://github.com/guardianproject/AndroidPluggableTransports
+n
_______________________________________________
tor-dev mailing list
tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev