Re: My tor exit node is gone from the node list?

[Roger Dingledine <arma@xxxxxxx>]

On Tue, Apr 28, 2009 at 04:33:35PM +0300, Alexandru Cezar wrote:
> For several months, we've been running a tor exit node (kyirong/A8BD
>32A9 C2F2 0C4F 8ED2 C26C E477 0A24 85E3 CD22). Since a few days, it
>seems to have vanished from the list of nodes, and I cannot make it
>reappear.

How odd. It is still publishing descriptors, and the directory
authorities are still testing its reachability. In particular, here
are the six votes from the six directory authorities:

moria1:
r kyirong hJ1FoyM1XrNPcy7120MLkGoh2q4 a8to9mHCh8NrHRXv2kYvWc80StA 2009-05-09 15:14:55 89.248.169.108 8010 80
s Exit Fast HSDir Running Unnamed V2Dir Valid

dizum:
r kyirong hJ1FoyM1XrNPcy7120MLkGoh2q4 a8to9mHCh8NrHRXv2kYvWc80StA 2009-05-09 15:14:55 89.248.169.108 8010 80
s V2Dir Valid

tor26:
r kyirong hJ1FoyM1XrNPcy7120MLkGoh2q4 a8to9mHCh8NrHRXv2kYvWc80StA 2009-05-09 15:14:55 89.248.169.108 8010 80
s Unnamed V2Dir Valid

ides:
r kyirong hJ1FoyM1XrNPcy7120MLkGoh2q4 a8to9mHCh8NrHRXv2kYvWc80StA 2009-05-09 15:14:55 89.248.169.108 8010 80
s Exit Fast HSDir Running V2Dir Valid

dannenberg:
r kyirong hJ1FoyM1XrNPcy7120MLkGoh2q4 a8to9mHCh8NrHRXv2kYvWc80StA 2009-05-09 15:14:55 89.248.169.108 8010 80
s Exit Fast HSDir Running V2Dir Valid

gabelmoo:
r kyirong hJ1FoyM1XrNPcy7120MLkGoh2q4 a8to9mHCh8NrHRXv2kYvWc80StA 2009-05-09 15:14:55 89.248.169.108 8010 80
s V2Dir Valid

Only three of the six are voting for the Running flag. Therefore it's
not considered running, and it's left out of the consensus (since nobody
would use it anyway).

So that's why it's missing. But, why is it not considered reachable from
three of them? I'm not sure.

--Roger