[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
Re: [tor-dev] Onion Service v2 Deprecation Timeline
- To: Alec Muffett <alec.muffett@xxxxxxxxx>, tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Subject: Re: [tor-dev] Onion Service v2 Deprecation Timeline
- From: meskio <meskio@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Tue, 16 Jun 2020 17:24:48 +0200
- Authentication-results: lesnaus.sindominio.net; dkim=pass (4096-bit key; unprotected) header.d=sindominio.net header.i=@sindominio.net header.b="E7suJa7/"; dkim-atps=neutral
- Autocrypt: : addr=meskio@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata=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 VS3/BeiUIL+GDPF3M4KIJvqTHC7TmSQAH1slVdceqJRQ6ZKnV9d2QvA82OF66h7G9oNsSfu1t9c2Tpe8rG+YCna8VzRIaDy/HhqsyBP3HbGcBvZv6JraRfzB6N63ZjDzVW8K780vV0glWyUZjM0LvwOFepXBrYS3gxbFUY+OwL8F8a5ZIp0TounbeCEGtiiHGprZ6/a4umAvajK7PytdvG3ETb8NNw6s8EfOJ9G9qMU8KvwtCQjqr5II3XPKafzN2XtVbr/knGfLx3dLlbinZy/gz5Pfbkd33kV/89o8z6e0oxrfJk+R1qQrRA1d/UeHg5VrzaV4MrY/4LYACguQ== '
- Delivered-to: archiver@xxxxxxxx
- Delivery-date: Tue, 16 Jun 2020 11:25:10 -0400
- Dkim-filter: OpenDKIM Filter v2.11.0 lesnaus.sindominio.net 43726365435
- Dkim-filter: OpenDKIM Filter v2.11.0 lesnaus.sindominio.net 1CBD9365438
- Dkim-filter: OpenDKIM Filter v2.11.0 lesnaus.sindominio.net 9448E364C2D
- Dkim-signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=sindominio.net; s=mail; t=1592321091; bh=aLEaYpM5Yf92VdN3YqAxqvg1Y9M+yvpn3WSgb+lgJ5M=; h=In-Reply-To:References:Subject:From:To:Date:From; b=E7suJa7/FbpbuEYwjJmaMV9txwcpMauhAqCg9+NPCjGLxqNtu3wq+A4hjzmsVVaMK dRcWJ/e7ZT4JatqriR/NRG4MxKeUwrq+vUK2PhnPka+Q8tBBgiJFJPr3UkuC1JmM9k TJgHnxWx8vxpDomOS5pmIzOf0qssfEhJCSGSdux+QudM58bQZRLDcXULxEF6xdLTop Trg6Mc1DFo+H6aBP8Z7dNRoorCZGL6uCVvV84wyCzA1LCF3ffiuIK4ctki418oYU6C VpmpVupE065QC6XQCAuO4kRWn1PQVsQ0YbuozcbKNfbGkjeeiwWXOuZjc/WA8rsWh4 sNpjaJOh6zwgLQlzj/6KWPwVdHCcx5dyXlCulitOpmIptYdJ89P2PwillEeBxvPxOt lNB9qwF9F4jR4usJMyKzj3WmYhez1ukdHivF05zYbv/7h9W9O2dULRbw4QqfT2NaSp SDB8PxnKmM39lKcKjSkxmFpoVk6GaU5lNrG+sUvI8us+gkSu+kCq/3tCXg2lUA0qgY SWgEhayzRPjScDRfVzgn4bW9xRUTjJCi8hdNeCVoEQDEJQ/B/RtLUYthara60CgxMg cVgcvSLl7HOOUh2BwxuGhgv422LyV1wqTM2sWMgW6nXKUZ8Y6L2+H8VI7/0jzz2zH6 lKKftlHmdMHh5rf1zgy2Ww+8=
- In-reply-to: <CAFWeb9Jxfkc6d6qQCjW-S+pJbWFPA9opWpVpRxq0NBmv6JbHFQ@mail.gmail.com>
- List-archive: <http://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-dev/>
- List-help: <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=help>
- List-id: discussion regarding Tor development <tor-dev.lists.torproject.org>
- List-post: <mailto:tor-dev@lists.torproject.org>
- List-subscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev>, <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=subscribe>
- List-unsubscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/options/tor-dev>, <mailto:tor-dev-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=unsubscribe>
- References: <20200615163417.g4wbevnf5hyy3xwb@raoul> <20200616083102.GB2640@moria.seul.org> <d3644341-a6fa-de19-2c37-d7025443112e@torproject.org> <159230611262.3310.12105751948063860571@localhost> <CAFWeb9Jxfkc6d6qQCjW-S+pJbWFPA9opWpVpRxq0NBmv6JbHFQ@mail.gmail.com>
- Reply-to: tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Sender: "tor-dev" <tor-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Quoting Alec Muffett (2020-06-16 14:10:24)
> On Tue, 16 Jun 2020 at 12:15, meskio <[1]meskio@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
>
> I'm wondering if it will make sense to use Onion-Location in V2 onion
> services
> to advertise the V3 onion. So existing known V2 services can use it to
> upgrade
> their users to V3.
>
> AFAIK right now tor-browser ignores the Onion-Location header if is
> already
> coming from an onion service. Will it make sense to stop ignoring it at
> least
> for V2 onion services?
>
> Or the site could just issue a Location header and/or explicit redirect to
> the v3 service?
> After all, if the v2 site is compromised to the point where that's a
> problem, then there are larger issues / "game over", etc.
True, I agree I don't see much value added to do the Onion-Location instead of
just doing a redirect. I guess this is a better way of upgrading users.
--
meskio | https://meskio.net/
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
My contact info: https://meskio.net/crypto.txt
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Nos vamos a Croatan.
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: signature
_______________________________________________
tor-dev mailing list
tor-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev