[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]
[tor-talk] New report: The State of Internet Censorship in Venezuela
- To: tor-talk@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Subject: [tor-talk] New report: The State of Internet Censorship in Venezuela
- From: Maria Xynou <maria@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Thu, 16 Aug 2018 19:51:53 +0200
- Autocrypt: addr=maria@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= xsFNBFTBumQBEADMQHFdgG0CJMpUxr3wRpfIGYBLhJCiMlFSI8SdlCM4aKtt4fh4jVqnaCEq ZkigQ3nCtcVMpTxvgFh7JCLRseBL5Za8dkO24vIrqwFDN5Qy1Twflo2D2ZTJshzO35161ugK L8o8YQGHHpKtdW/67Faakr34A8CG3MJkCU7OKm8DBGwdy7tPEGE3vPR+cjr0hGNa29CgD3oM 6jB9bQjudRy0MAc6fjTU9ZPskONztMoY6H9Lt/tKrcwaALRKJxxCvyldk+O6qQFn/JXt++4B q/n4twepUUd1Ijmw2blF0m2okEKZBHpFJuHAE2L3cttohg/IwevhRdKPEehaNYNoCkNVfTU1 /qRHmjkEON5AEwHweT7wf4gRAtXMSGb809hH0G8Fa8wjFbCWac1Pd+W+S+Wk6gtzGActkKNx 6mBVUPd4/RhMPvZXAESW8ISX4XX/4QdAGgmmAiD6SydhpTDbVOEUC2qWqTMpHIvW9w0jTPgI 9CPgF/VgLudi3QBl1FFdYA3feCLOkSxtRAX8p5AtmisnzEXYhQXBCrfgWlkeiDw4585xwdLR 6Vs75irqnpvv74hJKZdju0tVV77/HyKAptvONMn3Vzpkg3eXIc+kP2sudvfvaYUomlWqJouC UDeH7YJnQISinO2xwTkF0p+vZ0pN93JO3qROtaaf1B83+FZHTQARAQABzSdNYXJpYSBYeW5v dSA8bWFyaWFAb3Blbm9ic2VydmF0b3J5Lm9yZz7CwX8EEwECACkFAlc1wCoCGyMFCQlmAYAH CwkIBwMCAQYVCAIJCgsEFgIDAQIeAQIXgAAKCRAhMbO+cMpBfincEACe9XeiH49Ur2GlqdV5 RtUoB0PzZ8KWfMdVVoyemwRSh+PyYENqrr4k4E5LtE//3ZbiARF5VIkxJUYN32caQ+IRn0s7 yT3a1LuMjeZOd5EMnkflzuzDtBH8nyY6Oys/ZHRFJ4OVq6dvnHcQnWG1Oo+Gqj2Z6T9Za+16 U5GthmkUWm2T6XZLyfWvYIDHzp1wjrjhltvr2wdTDjXKh/JRC2v/rr/KEtDCReyHUVEbAE1k w0uryClVbkTbL1NG6q73xOlrPxr4EsHYDytFy7mLJ9kq1SsW/Cvcg58KcSsf3XdBB46ixhCn aeN9X72wP83mx5yPUjqnXNlfsrVHSYe7SLVneJe0v6q5ssfZMmxBBuBEXvVnCeZxNJuw4MTf Z6foniqC1lq7HRiKng56M7ljb36sPmWG5oNk2J5kgg+3fkSmnqMOqQpgQfPXtKySrNp5YZOg Oo/OsXqAHDDqww6J4D7rmLOhVJklW/UxBxeKGjDEE/8upsCeorlxrSbm+2bO1gma+CRNql4O tu/2+rJVhb10U9vhdaHpN6RNHHsdQ+jQLQ0w4nZx7JLM/ON84AT9YSl2L/+6aJ1cYcPYpfrj NXO0VuHn1RoeFMLHZv7ZC8+Ux1VpST63Psb5pZgTE2A9dBuCJ5csuVa618KJeP5SP5WCT/n1 Ygy7fouhqAJS8arlBc7BTQRUwbpkARAAnjGqtfmAvdt5qW52TpQZegI9luVtQNeSOejAV/3y Kr+W5U0g0nyvKW872rCpZdtlrvU1hD1LGVvgSOJxTd8cg7Tq1tKNLMUTke5IiyihlmPsWRL2 eG5ikLkdduuYvycAgbEJfkv5KW68x99K0xh7cB8LEB4lyXcgnB7Z7evrhDPK+EhebmXHdmuq jc3q+Pyb6+mV5dtQ7X1Tl3PgLrNRO9Jxe2rrpN1HEeey+qUMoFqLsl+/uNkL4DsXiGLlFFhv p3nL+VuG7mL+zpu2QO0nc/0NvBWNrtZA3GhlTpLv8Nj6PNGNgA636NgI5o/hwVSb8JmVok4u fOxFZO8qlPpv2Gv3QaGf6oHSxmpmSaMpE75hknT3w7mtnmH9ixoTeNBKkTLw0OGBuR40CZE1 J+Chq+XJy99n/Jqpn5pal1FgdPvzNNJU5qed+5nExuiYp5qXkw8neFPXE0twt9cHbgTgOxuf XTiH+aQWHIv378H2VkPr7wxvoFguaco8ykEMl8DnPgya0zrvKIVZEUtgebMC52JOe3PWgY+Q vvHcx2QQ+oARiDQEi9+sORk+C/xyf568hS/pSCcUo+q7+C0ndDLTj/3BSUVi9VSi++b6TaRR fR+n6ASSAD2KLVLbvTjxi/xfcC6HPsCXu7VEYACZVrpWmPDXdY1hr++uelLCxGgEFOEAEQEA AcLBZQQYAQIADwUCVMG6ZAIbDAUJCWYBgAAKCRAhMbO+cMpBfuL5EACDb8QcTCGedyoxoyXU GGT71Lnyo3/HDbJv/5FFKEqnfUyZzqWNzAwWyFTCIqCghXxAfMfC70DZXyIiuuRqztVXIu7T VXsCPX/sUi3EIrc3MNN570EN4SmIZ7JIavkuj7yzcaJl1uzDF8M3HZm76KvWXPlRD5KdmZYE Z6mcQUlmei+HjkSUZc/9SKsyW4bGaGKAhgI7TXDs5nYgMRwUsH0VXqLYA549ipgvVvqrwZQn x7UkRsbf+vdK1rlhX59J+Qr4A4Yaccba0jSg0JP1EV6vFt5K6h1/2X4YnYcE5XSrpB3iFOGg pIrxjnf5OHtEC55Rq08C/7qohJfyTW+FEIPTDpzowJZxIt+7JXx/3OOoVI9nfN9sbXn5MlQQ +INRmNa72vQ20g1luYvQhK4BLrizOuGqg5p//5CQtLQ0qRvwz+56FlL0PGb222Fr5CH+G8+m RELfdfurMFCjcSIKN8iyzRsZYHZrO4XmoqJXIwNMqWkZLjiVgec2t/PQU6N80IxjGIbTalG7 tJsYd0QhSyxRjRazRNUMsrP2rl338AEUApm0Wbp2GWUPF7gZR/m4ZWXDm+2jPGKeHnp7B5qK 1rClE5fl3oUCGiBSSL++/b+yw6SotQTXEm8yEDv/t6p0VNVVG0oAZIB8ZtZIgiGSRTkLUm+N +GTD9Dc/tYsyXOVNTw==
- Delivered-to: archiver@xxxxxxxx
- Delivery-date: Thu, 16 Aug 2018 13:52:06 -0400
- Dkim-signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=openobservatory-org.20150623.gappssmtp.com; s=20150623; h=to:from:subject:openpgp:autocrypt:message-id:date:user-agent :mime-version:content-transfer-encoding:content-language; bh=DNCf65VStiwoLaUGWMr/wltXEllCQXa5nrOR3cNVY+0=; b=Zqj42QYPkudaoul61jCjGkgONvkQ/ot1MlYtXjslsnVfu6Kcw427dsXAWuHnofzMKf PXfmWPZIRiwhImT8HDqun1D917daWQroDloJAXgUM2yhPirMaBNtJuM0Wamc7N3UP82A c36C8COYDmzJZ6r1bzfI//gTIzvIvKcw9Rkr8cab6Otrqtwy6JcUionRSxWQAs8H9VlF F/PyihCoXWaXt9ydOHVyVIsktD7h3FrafDcl2HkN+7G1CTQFX57pIIbNL11H1P1M8+WF I31M3W2pUCTJ8DIAag1g9qvtSiufWfdetot2hIBLK5OyzrqxTz8g83A181JqcDWTBew/ OmjQ==
- List-archive: <http://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-talk/>
- List-help: <mailto:tor-talk-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=help>
- List-id: "all discussion about theory, design, and development of Onion Routing" <tor-talk.lists.torproject.org>
- List-post: <mailto:tor-talk@lists.torproject.org>
- List-subscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-talk>, <mailto:tor-talk-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=subscribe>
- List-unsubscribe: <https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/options/tor-talk>, <mailto:tor-talk-request@lists.torproject.org?subject=unsubscribe>
- Openpgp: preference=signencrypt
- Reply-to: tor-talk@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Sender: "tor-talk" <tor-talk-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:52.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/52.9.1
Hello,
Today Venezuela Inteligente, IPYS Venezuela and OONI jointly published a
research report examining internet censorship in Venezuela.
Our research report is available here:
https://ooni.torproject.org/post/venezuela-internet-censorship/
Our study is based on the analysis of hundreds of thousands of OONI
Probe network measurements collected from multiple local vantage points
over the last 4 years.
Key findings include:
1. Media censorship: A number of independent media websites are
blocked (primarily by means of DNS tampering) by (at least) 4 Venezuelan
ISPs. These include El Pitazo and El Nacional, two of Venezuela's major,
independent news outlets known for reporting extensively on corruption
(and other political issues). All 3 of El Pitazo's domains
(elpitazo.info, elpitazo.com, elpitazo.ml) were found to be blocked
across ISPs (possibly in an attempt to reinforce the censorship).
Over the last days, state-owned CANTV appears to have started blocking
investigative journalism site armando.info as well (by means of HTTP
blocking). This though requires further testing, since some measurements
aren't consistent.
2. Blogs expressing political criticism, Zello (heavily used by
protesters), and a number of currency exchange websites were found to be
blocked. This suggests that internet censorship in Venezuela may be a
symptom of its economic and political crisis.
3. Tor blocking: We were able to confirm the blocking of the Tor
network and obfs4 by state-owned CANTV through OONI measurements and
through a number of additional tests and experiments. Our report shares
relevant data (in tsv files). The blocking started about two months ago,
and appears to be ongoing.
Overall, internet censorship in Venezuela doesn't appear to be
centralized, since different ISPs were found to adopt different
censorship techniques and censor different platforms. Moreover, ISPs
don't always appear to roll out the same censorship in all regions (for
example, CANTV appears to block armando.info in Caracas, but not in
other states).
The recent blocking of Tor and (more) independent media sites signifies
that internet censorship in Venezuela is potentially becoming more
pervasive. Further research and testing is therefore required.
You can expand upon our study through the use of OONI Probe
(https://ooni.torproject.org/install/) and OONI data
(https://ooni.torproject.org/data/).
Thanks for reading!
Best,
Maria.
--
Maria Xynou
Research & Partnerships Director
Open Observatory of Network Interference (OONI)
https://ooni.torproject.org/
PGP Key Fingerprint: 2DC8 AFB6 CA11 B552 1081 FBDE 2131 B3BE 70CA 417E
--
tor-talk mailing list - tor-talk@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe or change other settings go to
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-talk