Re: Hints and Tips for Whistleblowers - their comments on Tor and SSL - I don't understand.

[Sebastian Hahn <mail@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

On Oct 27, 2010, at 8:19 PM, Matthew wrote:

> Hello,
>
> There is a “Hints and Tips for Whistleblowers Guide” available at http://ht4w.co.uk/ 
> .
>
> The section on proxies includes Tor-related information which I fail  
> to understand:
>
>
> "You may actually get more anonymity when using the Tor cloud by not  
> using the https:// version of a web page (if there is an  
> alternative, unencrypted version available), since all the Tor  
> traffic is encrypted anyway between your PC and the final exit node  
> in the Tor cloud, which will probably not be physically in the  
> United Kingdom."
>
>
> ---I have no idea what this means. I thought the whole point of  
> using https:// was to prevent Tor exit nodes from snooping and / or  
> potentially injecting content.
>
>
> "This applies especially to websites like the reasonably anonymous  
> whistleblowing website wikileaks.org (based in Sweden) , which offer  
> both http://, https:/and Tor Hidden Service methods of uploading  
> whistleblower leak documents, but who tend to, mistakenly, insist on  
> using https:// encryption for when someone comments on their wiki  
> discussion pages. When (not if) the wikileaks.org servers, or a blog  
> or a discussion forum like the activist news site Indymedia UK are  
> physically seized (this happened to IndyMedia UK at least 3 times  
> now) , this may, in some circumstances, betray the real IP addresses  
> of commentators with inside knowledge of a whistleblower leak i.e.  
> suspects for a leak investigation."
>
>
> -----How on earth can it be “mistaken” to insist on using https://  
> encryption?  Why would using https:// "betray the real IP addresses"

Hi,

Wow. This is really dangerous misinformation, and I'm wondering what
kind of person would give such intentionally harmful advice, marketing
it at whistleblowers. Tor explicitly recommends using https wherever
possible, whether you are using Tor or not. You're right to be
suspicious of their advice. Attacking wikileaks for forcing the use of
https is also just ridiculous.

Sebastian***********************************************************************
To unsubscribe, send an e-mail to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx with
unsubscribe or-talk    in the body. http://archives.seul.org/or/talk/